Chuck Season 1 - GAME OVER

[Energetic Penguin]

Hey, did you miss me guys?

*looks over at PeregrineV*

VOTE: MasterMind of Sin

I just skimmed through the posts, I'll take a second look and make some comments tonight.

[Energetic Penguin]

hrmm, Ima post in the morning. I'm not getting much of any scumvibes right now.

[Energetic Penguin]

How about we all restate our cases so we can re-examine them and see if we still find them valid.

My case on Energetic Penguiin:


All right. Let's hear everyone elses cases!

This image is win. I tried to resize it for my avy but now there's no animation. Is there a way to fix that?

[Energetic Penguin]

WARNING INCOMING WALL O TEXT!

This is a catchup post reponding to stuff spanning the whole thread so far.

Please, at the very least respond to the comments and questions directed at you.

Also, scum team is Ragnarokio and ooba. Discuss.

How serious was this post?

Protecting a scumbuddy with your favorite chainsaw, huh? *rev, revvvv*

Vote: Thor665

Thor made a legitimate point and you're just OMGUS voting and being silly.

omg o-0

Just stating intent to unvoteif we reach 5 on the mbf wagoon. There is probably already mafia on the wagon, but when it reaches 5 people, then it becomes an insane RVS wagon.

Who do you think the scum on his wagon are?

I am going to oppose the ooba wagon as well. MarchHare has come in here and basically went "oh hey. There guys are scum. Lynch please".

FoS:MarchHare

Why no vote change here? MBF has done nothing scummy, and if someone else has actually done something Fos worthy, why not make it a vote?

unvote vote: Ragnarokio

Your posts are a waste of space. Fluff on page 4 is not a great idea in a small game.

That wasn't really fluff, Rag was inquiring about March hare. Sure there they may have been short posts, but there was an exchange of information.

Original Roll String: 1d13

1 13-Sided Dice: (7) = 7

*previews*

Damnit, no more dice tags!? What has this world come to?

Random.org Result: 13

Vote: MarchHare

This is very dumb. There are 4 pages of posts and the only thing you do is randomly vote? As in an actual random vote instead of commenting?

Danakillsu, how is fluff a few pages into the game a scum tell?

If you're FOSing Ragnarokio for fluff you should be FOSing everyone else who hasn't said anything meaningful.

This

Dodgy answer is dodgy.

I'm pushing it because thus far I have one town read, a handfull of 'I hate them because they're lurkers' reads, and the rest all stand equal. I want to lynch someone, thus I chose Mikey boy - call it gut and him not deigning to respond to the wagon to show how "cool, calm, and town he is." I say it's lurking out because he's scum.

Why are you against the wagon?

What do you mean respond to the wagon. There's been no real reason given for all these votes, so what is he supposed to defend against?

@ MarchHare
Just trying to put some pressure on someone with at least a little reasoning. I hate your repeated attempts to make us think we can't find scum on page x.

unvote vote: MarchHare

Huh? Didn't he just say that he's pegged before on Page 5?

Also, my patented WagonAnalysis™ 3000 dictates that the most probable scumbuddies on this wagon are:

Ragnarokio
PeregrineV

I disagree, I think they're both town actually. Less sure about Pere tho.

[Energetic Penguin]

so, I'm liking my vote on Mastermind of sin since he's only posted twice, came in ignored everything that happened and made a vote that was completely random, thus not moving the game forward one bit.

[Energetic Penguin]

I'm currently Iso'ing people and narrowing down my scumspects.

Dana, could you share with us your feelings on MarchHare as the game progressed?

I have no idea > crazy active lurker > intentional content-less poster > scum pretending not to understand any of my points on him. Or at the very least scum not trying to understand my points on him.

I don't really get this, Marchhare's posts may be short but there's definitely content in them.

[Energetic Penguin]

Mastermind, you're wrong. The RVS is where people generally prod one another and a random wagon comes up. then we may get some reads and some serious discussion is born out of it. Your vote is actually random whereas during the RVS they may be dumb reasons or mostly nonexistant but only semi random. If you let us know its random it diminishes its point even further. Given you did this after people had said noteworthy things is quite scummy. You have also so far managed to post no game related content. Why do you not want to comment on anything that's happened?

@Dana: MoS is definitely an active lurker. Any reason you're not concerned with him?

[Energetic Penguin]

HEY RC, any way I can join this alliance?

[Energetic Penguin]

but but, MOS isnt even trying. March Hare is looking for scum. How's march scummier?

I'm really not liking MoS and MBF excusing their inactivity, by saying there's too much fluff. My current guess for the scumteam is them + dana.

[Energetic Penguin]

but even after your random vote you have nothing relevant to say. This is pretty close,

Perhaps if you guys didn't spam up the topic so much, it would be worth MoS's time.

This.

[Energetic Penguin]

but but, MOS isnt even trying. March Hare is looking for scum. How's march scummier?

I'm really not liking MoS and MBF excusing their inactivity, by saying there's too much fluff. My current guess for the scumteam is them + dana.

Pfffff. I like how you didn't bother to respond to what I actually said and just drew the conclusions I knew you were going for anyway. You have nothing there but a presupposition.
I disagree that MarchHare is really looking for scum. He is not trying any more than MoS, he's just better at making it look good. Even after I said that his one-line posts were not helping anything, he continued to make them. How can you call that pro-town? March is scummier for reasons I have already stated. He actually has enough content in his posts to peg him as likely scum, whereas MoS just looks like someone that does that sort of thing all the time.

You're attacking him for playstyle reasons. There's nothing inherently scummy about one line posts. Just because you tell him its scummy does not make it so. March siad the MBF wagon was terribad. So other than him derailing a wagon and making 1-line posts (which isn't scummy) what is this content that incriminates him?

@RC: you didnt answer me. Can I join the alliance?

[Energetic Penguin]

I'm sorry but my answer looks something like "*shrug* I thought it would be cool"

I've never seen an alliance in a mafia game and I thought it would be fun.

[Energetic Penguin]

UNVOTE: MoS
VOTE: Danakillsu

[Energetic Penguin]

lol@ Dana, I merely forgot to place my vote earlier. There's no way for me to prove this, but this has little to do with RC agreeing with me.

Also, it seems you're just going after easy lynches. I've played with Pere a good bit and this is normal town play from him.

[Energetic Penguin]

MoS has not done a single real thing all game and has not been trying to hide it.

That's a town tell, in my opinion, but it's annoying.

Yes, but this sort of attitude gives him a free pass as scum to say nothing important. It turns into WIFOM quickly. He's also been rather deflective about this.

[Energetic Penguin]

@Dana: did you read RC's post? RC has listed several wasy they help, you wanna refute his argument or just be contentious?

[Energetic Penguin]

I think the scum team is Thor, Ant and MOS.

@Mod: dana is not self-voting - its on PeregrineV ..

What's the reasoning behind Thor and Ant?

[Energetic Penguin]

Deadline is in about 6 days. I'm fine with a Thor lynch. Looks like every single person unvoted me while I wasn't paying attention. That's cool.

Huh? Why do you wanna lynch Thor? That just seems like OMGUS to me. Are you just gonna sit by while waiting for the deadline to pass? Because that's the impression I get from this post.

That's a safe bet, RC.

In other news, I just looked at the player list and was surprised to see someone I did not even realize was playing this game. Then I went back and looked at his posts, and I saw my definition of active lurking.

Unvote, Vote: animorpherv1

Stop pretending to contribute!

Nice Hypocrisy scum.

Reading up and commenting. I'm busy today with stuff so I'll be on during intervals respond to things that have happened.

[Energetic Penguin]

Ok I might have been wrong on that scum team call ..
- I will not support a MBF, MOS, dana lynch (Deadlines exceptions excluded but would like to avoid it - Given a choice amongst three to avoid NL I'd go MOS>dana>MBF)
- I retract my RC town read
- I would like Thor lynched

Do you still suspect Ant? Why did you change your mind on MoS?

wagon on Ant is weak.

@I don't like that you listed MBF as townread. Your sole reason is that getting to L-2 as scum is unlikely. Why? There's no reason why it would require both his scumbuddies to be on him either. MBF is looking quite scummy to me.

[Energetic Penguin]

OOPS, fixed below, I'd like Magua to respond.

Ok I might have been wrong on that scum team call ..
- I will not support a MBF, MOS, dana lynch (Deadlines exceptions excluded but would like to avoid it - Given a choice amongst three to avoid NL I'd go MOS>dana>MBF)
- I retract my RC town read
- I would like Thor lynched

Do you still suspect Ant? Why did you change your mind on MoS?

wagon on Ant is weak.

@

Magua

: I don't like that you listed MBF as townread. Your sole reason is that getting to L-2 as scum is unlikely. Why? There's no reason why it would require both his scumbuddies to be on him either. MBF is looking quite scummy to me.

[Energetic Penguin]

I admit to not contrbuting to this game as much as I should.

Unvote