Amrun 183 wrote:RC, I voted for Kcdaspot, but votes don't count towards lynch in this game. It's effectively an FoS and I don't see a problem with doing that.
Liar, liar, pants on fire.
Vote: Amrun
Amrun 183 wrote:Also, I fail to see how asking a direct question of Exe is WIFOM.
Cute. You think I'm going to fall for that? You know full well what you're doing. I've played this game too long. We both know perfectly well what point you were making. WIFOM isn't necessarily scummy, but it sure as heck ain't townie. You trying to act so cute and innocent about it definitely tips it from null to scummy.
By the by, you are actually going on the top of my list, hon. No joke.
---
Chrono 193 wrote:Working on the assumption of three:
Ranger
Smargret
{Doombunny/EXE}
I look forward to you expanding on this.
---
Mist 197 wrote:I forgot that votes were secret. I have bad memory.
Are you going to commit to this game or not? This is the second time you've given us this. Read over the rules or replace out. I know the Mod asked us specifically not to replace out, but, I suspect he would much rather you do it now than after D1.
---
Ranger 203 wrote:I don't think the questions that Doombunny asked are in any way helpful to finding scum, and thus I see no reason to answer them. That's my general feeling on RQS. I recognize that this feeling isn't terribly common or popular, but it does not reflect on my alignment.
I, for one, could care less if you answer them or not. However, if you choose not to answer them, then you better damn well contribute to the game (not to say that people who
do
answer them don't have to contribute, but you get my point).
Ranger 203 wrote:Looking over Doombunny9's ISO, he has been consistently posting without doing any serious scum hunting. He's pointed out the problems in other people's theories, and has occasionally agreed with them, but he has yet to put forward any original ideas, and he hasn't done anything to help with finding scum.
I don't get how you could have a scumread on Amrun and a worse one on Doombunny. It's clear that he was helping pressure Amrun here. I mean, did he not, in your opinion, do so genuinely? You say that he's not doing any serious scumhunting, but one of his main targets is Amrun. This just seems a little backwards when you say this.
---
GW 215 wrote:Of note on this last one is the last line. Apparently, you can catch scum with the first one being used as the majority of discussion.
Also, note that he says that we should have more going on by page 3 of a game with extremely weird mechanics. Before that post, Amrun began to suspect Kcda, Smar had begun pointing at Amrun about interaction with Kcda, Exe was pressuring Kcda, and Trow was pressuring Exe. Seems like a good start to me, whilst discussing game related mechanics. I assume mafia know a bit more of the mechanics than we do and he wanted to keep it that way. The buddying to me he feels like he's been doing also bugs me. Especially when talking about Kcda buddying to Amrun.
This is a much better observation than Ranger put together. I think you make some good points here and have some creditable ideas. This gives my Doombunny townread a bit of a blow, for sure.
---
smargaret 216 wrote:Do we want to release the top three living names on our lists? I'm worried that if we don't and if scum communicates we could wind up with two obvious townies on the chopping block.
I'm releasing my whole list, and I encourage others to do the same. Now, if people don't want to based on silly political views that "townreads should be hidden" or whatever, then, okay, I'm not going to push on that too hard. I don't want to get into a political debate over townreads. Let's just make a truce that if someone doesn't want to give out their townreads, I won't get pissy at them, but, in turn, they can't get pissy when I release my full list. If someone has a problem with this, they need to speak up.
---
Grey 218 wrote:Top 3 if we went right now?
1) Chronopie
Quit trolling.
Grey 220 wrote:Amrun on kcda is not scum on scum, try again smarg. This time with less waffles.
Maybe not, but one of them is scum and we can stand to lose them both. Just sayin'.
Grey 226 wrote:Skimming the thread is one thing. He didn't even bother to check what was going on, just called the biggest debate TvT. Which was Amrun v. kcdaspot... and he didn't even remember Amrun.
I'll give you this. I think he skimmed too, but that is certainly not the biggest scumtell around. Get real, Grey. Especially with all your page 4 nonsense, I think you're doing this for the shock value more than anything else.
---
smargaret 231 wrote:The last time I see you listing suspects is on Saturday afternoon, Amrun - has nothing changed in your opinion since then?
What's your point? This is kind of antsy sounding. Why would she change her suspicions every two days? It's not like there were any big revelations since then. I don't know what you're trying to get at here.
---
Exe 232 wrote:Essentially, you're doing exactly what Chrono is doing: attempting to appear pro-town by calling for relevant discussion, without actually giving any relevant discussions.
Also, your apology for your absence shows that you're clearly more concerned with making peace to notice the real issue, which is a scumtell in my book.
I agree with this completely, but it should be noted that Chrono has a townie leg to stand on with his first post. Chrono should be seen as town far before Ranger, regardless of either players skimming.
---
Amrun 233 wrote:I really am town, though. I tend to suck early game as town. I don't know why. This is something I really need to work on.
Oh, cry my a river. "Poor me! I'm so town but I can't get it across! Boo hoo! I don't know why! I promise I'll work on it... just don't suspect me, please! ;_;"
Amrun 238 wrote:kcdaspot and I are OBVIOUSLY not scum together. I mean, seriously. It should be obvious.
No, that's not obvious at all. It's perfectly standard for scum to distance from their buddies. It's not "obvious" that people who suspect each other can't be scum together.
Amrun 242 wrote:To clarify, to say that both kcdaspot and I are both scum without some sort of extensive explanation as to how this is possible (which I have not seen) is just throwing vague suspicion on the two people that have stirred up the most shit so far and looks very much like opportunistic scum to me.
I've got a perfect reasoning. I don't care for either of y'alls play so it wouldn't phase me in the slightest with losing either of you as town for the chance at lynching one or both of you as scum.
The fact that you're so virulently against it just makes me want to do it more, you know.
---
Kcda 243 wrote:amrun.. Chrono has the worst post all game. and so... why am i still scum on page 10?
What a horrible reason. You care to elaborate, or are you perfectly fine with looking like you're piggybacking on Grey?
Oh, by the way, why me = fry me, friend.
---
Tragedy 245 wrote:Hell, RC goes missing once in a while. 0.0
It's not really missing, I just don't post as often as you guys do. I don't check the site from my phone. I work and go to school full time. When I log on, I like to catch up on all of my games in one extended sitting for the most part.
Anyways, Amrun knows I've been afk since we're in another game together, she's just trying to make some noise in order to call attention away from her scumminess.
---
- Amrun
- Kcdaspot
- RangeroftheNorth
- smargaret
- Mist7676
- Doombunny9
- Tragedy
- MrTrow
- Exe
- GreyICE
- Chronopie
- GhostWriter
I'll probably be putting my list in every post from this point forth. It's 12 players long because I'm obviously on the bottom of my list (as I'd expect everyone else to put themselves).