Mini 870: Melee mafia. (Mod Abandoned)

[SpyreX]

/confirm Sorry for the delay

[SpyreX]

So, how abouts this for a starter:

I see no reason why actions should be PM'd. All combat should occur in the thread - especially since it appears as though dicerolls will be taken care of in thread as well.

[SpyreX]

I was going to respond to that wall of words quote-by-quote but I'll skip that.

Treat this like a mafia game and not a mismash. We discuss, we pick a target and

everyone attacks that target.

Further, if all attacks are made in thread that eliminates even the chance for mafia to attempt to do anything but what is agreed upon.

Despite how much you want to deduce anything about my role from what I said (which I have issues with as is because there's not a good reason for it) I have made no claims about any feats, etc I have because it is irrelevant to the fact that unless I have a feat that is "win the game" eliminating the shroud for the mafia outweighs it.

We CAN lynch every night. Further, we CAN control it because there's no damage being spread out.

[SpyreX]

Sigh. Its going to be that kind of game. Nothing like apathy seeping in on page 2.

@Mod: If actions are PM'd to you and the results are posted do said results include the name of who undertook the action?

Your post betrays an assumption that you have made. It's out there for everyone (including scum) to see and invites townies to share the same information about themselves. At least one other player (tajo) has already followed your invitation. This is important to stop before it continues.

And your statement and this and all others in fact is holding to the assumption that regardless of what abilities I may have this is still the right course of action. Wooo

Of course the fact you are arguing that in-thread actions will, ultimately, hurt the town more than help because of

mystic roles

well.

[SpyreX]

Votes are far from useless and yes we should be using them.

If you feel like volunteering I'm down. I'd rather not.

[SpyreX]

Well if we see who attacks who regardless then I don't care as much.

Although that is ambiguous enough that IF we go to this PM format and I die to "an ogre" instead of a player name kill Kise asap.

[SpyreX]

-Who is Kise? Kast is not Kise. The implication that Kast is proposing we use some "PM format" is misleading and your proposed reaction to death by "an ogre" makes no sense. The claim that some player named Kise (or anything else) is proposing we use some "PM format" is not supported by any posts so far in this game.

Yea how could I have made that mistake.

And how could one ever assume if I go "do it in thread" and you go "NO" that the implication would be anything else.

3 pages in and I already don't care. That's pretty awesome and a new lap record.

Vote: Kast

[SpyreX]

Its winter though I need to horde it for the hibernation.

Nuwen: town.
Tajo: town.

These are true things.

Not attacking is fine. Attacking different targets isn't. Nuwen speaks gospel regarding attacking someone else.

[SpyreX]

^

This is exactly the issue with the system that is trying to be eliminated.

However, whatevs'.

P.S. if I have to scroll to read a post I'm not reading it.

[SpyreX]

Which would be fine if you were the only one who could do it. The problem arises when everyone starts doing it - its like having a mess of vigs and the issues it causes.

Then, of course, the other side is a bunch of people that are wounded are just asking to get picked off in the great harvest.

[SpyreX]

Melee phase is not equivalent to night in this game. Attacking a player is equivalent to an ability that has a %chance to permanently lower the voting threshold for that specific player.

This doesn't make sense in relation to the rules as stated or I'm missing something.

Its alive or dead. No voting. We pick a person (or two) and do our damndest to kill them. Then night as standard.

[SpyreX]

Huzzah. This isn't going to be my cup of tea, I can tell already.

Time for rule 1:

@Mod: Replacing out.