Mini #556 - The Most Excellent People Ever - Called.

[Oman]

I would like to say that I doubt Korlash as scum for the moment. I just don't think 425 fits with Lloyd bussing korlash for reals at all.

[Oman]

Thought I posted this...oh well:

From the looks of things he seems to direct attention at himself if he's Town, and he isn't doing that now. There were no dice, so his vote on me was hardly random. He has an agenda. For this, I feel a vote is in order to apply pressure, as Town he shouldn't worry, but if he is mafia, than he will crack.

Jester 4th-5th? votes Korlash with a horrible, horrible excuse for a vote. Not only is this flawed, its also hardly unique to scum.

Wow... If I didn't know the way you played as scum I would think yoru town now. But Your not. weird... Means my vote sticks.

IF either of them are scum, the other is.

Urza: For wanting Korlash to be hammered and lynched for no apparent reason. It's page 3, why for the love of god would you want someone lynched right now. I'm also assuming your not a total newb cause I have seen you at MTGS and if I remember correctly, you have mafia over there. Give me a *good* reason why korlash should be lynched.

UA: Simply cause I don't like his joking about Unlynchable scum claims at the 3 spot.

RotN: DO NOT PUT SOMEONE AT -1 WITHOUT A GOOD REASON AND NOT ON PAGE 2 Vote:RotN

The Jester: Awesome WIFOM and really no reason to put Korlash at -2 and I just have a really bad feeling about this guy. Seriously though, who uses the "If I were scum" arguement.

The best post so far. I can't believe people overlooked this. Your lynch should have come from this list.

I am challenging the traditional meta that d1s need to go slow, and also challenging the traditional meta that discussion is always a good thing.

I've found that people who attempt to challenge metas are often town, but often don't give much to the town because its not their priority.

Jesus this is an annoyingly hard read.

He recomended no-lynch, acted pointlessly serious for no good reason at Korlash, and has basicly defended himself in a piss poor way. He really deserves a fourth vote, at least. Vote:Jester

Oh so epic fail.

Last votecount of the day:

{1} Korlash (Guardian)

Intending to switch

{1} Guardian(Thanatos)

{1} DizzyIzzyB13 (tyhess)

Absent and town.

{7} Lloyd (UltimaAvalon, Panzerjager, The Jester, lovo14, WhoMe?, Lloyd, Korlash)

{1} Thanatos (Cavebear with a toothache)


I think the scums are WhoMe? and Korlash.

Is it possible that someone could be both scum and not scum? What about on an Austrian banknote?

[Oman]

Vote Korlash

WHoops.

[Oman]

Anyone (besides Korlash) disagree?

He should be lynched, this is pretty obvious.

Then why aren't you voting him?

That question is difficult to answer.

Use your words.

[Oman]

EPIC FAIL GUARDIAN!

Why do you want to claim now?

[Oman]

Guardian, I don't think that quoting the line breaks the rules.

[Oman]

Oh right, its kinda dicey, ask the mod.

BTW: The claim doesn't sit right with me. Its more a sniper role, and I don't think Johnny was a sniper in any way.

[Oman]

hmmm

what are the situations in which you can vig. I doubt that is breaking role PM conditions. If that is, just saying you're a vig is.

[Oman]

How about a korlash claim? Then I can decide, cause I sorta wanna vote guardian here.

Unvote

[Oman]

Unvote Vote WhoMe?

Yarly.

[Oman]

Substanative reasons? Or just bullshit gut reasons?

[Oman]

Meh, I say we just kill him. Lets get a true vig to take him out or someone incapacitate.

[Oman]

Siddartha Gautama - Postponed Omniscient If I survive until Day 5 I get to see the alignments of remaining players. I was also warned of a handicap. I was not informed as to what it was..but I feel it has something to with with Battlemage.

Not sure what to think of this. It would be a good fakeclaim, because if it is true it means we want to keep you alive. Why do you think your handicap is Battlemage related if you were not given information on it?

[Oman]

Thats enough for me. 95% is very serious.

Unvote Vote Panzer

We have scum in at least one of you.

[Oman]

BM is getting much better. In fact, he's pretty high quality now. Not too mention a top bloke.

[Oman]

Yup. He claimed a role that wasn't his, thats scum right there.

Disclaimer: Battlemage owns Rosso.

[Oman]

he didn't though.

He came up BM

in a closed setup, usually.

[Oman]

BM fits a miller role for me though. Flavour-wise.

I just...don't think its worth the risk to leave scum alive cause they may be a miller.

[Oman]

I've mispelled my name before (veggie mafia) its dumb to lynch over.

[Oman]

Panzer, I probably would've believed one or the other, but right now, you're claiming NK immune miller vig.

[Oman]

*sigh* I got lynched in PEGBAM because I was an NK immune SK but not inv Immune. I decided to claim all portions of my role but try to sound town at the same time, not thinking the cop hadn't investigated me.

I claimed (essentially) NK immuner miller vig and was promptly lynched for the basic overcomplication of the role.

Thats what Panzer is doing, he is claiming Facets of his role (like miller) that are neccessary because he's been investigated, whilst still trying to get us to keep him around.

Essetially: Cop, townie, doctor, vig even . all fly as fakeclaims because they're simple. delayed Omniscient miller is not, and does not.

[Oman]

Worth thinking about if

we

lynch him?

Not joining us?

[Oman]

Panzer, in pegbam I claimed a lot of my role, squashing roles together to make mine. I feel you are doing the same thing but making up a completely new role.

[Oman]

Directing the cop is the dumbest move, not because its scummy, but cause 80% of the time its horribly ineffectual.

[Oman]

Since when does knowing your a miller and closed game set-up have anything to do with each other. There are secret mod notes all the times. This game is in coney island you know. Its themed, anything can happen, less rules apply. Now your just reaching.

Unless I feel otherwise, I will follow standard meta.

[Oman]

FoS Guardian

The WIFOM is too big for me to think about voting him or not voting him based on that tomorrow.

[Oman]

If there was a jester in a mini this is the last time I play a Rosso game.

Srsly, my role is another reason.

[Oman]

If Panzer is scum one of his buddies should really tell us now.

[Oman]

Also, you're adopted, so thats funny too.

BTW: Thats gotta be the best line in the whole game.

[Oman]

Still at Uni, am lazy as sin, don't stress much.

Hoepfully I'm dropping out soon

[Oman]

I'm seriously considering taking the over right about now. :p

Do you have the setup. Just take it to night.

[Oman]

Oh taking THE over. Right I read now.

[Oman]

But who has the setup?

[Oman]

I'm no one carebear....no one...

That's CAVEbear, with a 'v'. >_> Maybe I really should change my avatar.

And we'd contact list mod first. Meme I guess.

[Oman]

I was Schrodinger, the guy with the cat.

I was town, I could choose to keep the cat in the box or let it out each night.

I was not told it did anything. (and I really hate those roles!)

[Oman]

Yep, thats him.

[Oman]

Indeed. Playing with no scum for 2 days would be lame.