Mini Normal 1888 - TwoFace Mafia - Game Over

[Eddie Cane]

that doesn't answer my question. how do you think I should have reacted?

[Eddie Cane]

what advantage does wheme stand to gain by selecting the next player as either alignment?

[Eddie Cane]

that doesn't account for fakeclaim traps, the fact he was going to likely go first anyways, and the fact it's just a really tiny advantage and if scum didn't have fakeclaims ready from the night that would be sad. if you want to be technical barley should choose the order everyone claims because we have the luxury of mod confirmed town. it's such a minor difference that I personally don't care and don't get why this is monopolizing discussion.

[Eddie Cane]

8 ppl alive + (probable idr if it's necessarily essential) 3 scum + gerry vote = no qh so it's /fine/ but should still prob be unvoted for now

[Eddie Cane]

Sorry I was not able to contribute much yesterday. I will be hopefully much more active today. Here is my first round of VCA. This is from day 1.

Spoiler: Day 1 vote counts

Vote count 1.03

aronagrundy - DogWatch, gerryoat (L-5)
Dogwatch -

mozamis

, Shadow_step (L-5)

Shadow_Step (Boonskiie's slot)

- Eddie Cane, FireScreamer (L-5)
Keyser Soze - Transcend,

Barleycorn

(L-5)

Transcend

- NorskaBlue (L-6)
gerryoat - Keyser Söze (L-6)
Eddie Cane - aronagrundy (L-6)

FireScreamer - Pants98 (Momo's slot)

(L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch

Vote count 1.04

aronagrundy - DogWatch, gerryoat (L-5)
Dogwatch -

mozamis

,

Shadow_step

(L-5)

Shadow_Step

- Eddie Cane, FireScreamer (L-5)
Keyser Soze -

Transcend, Barleycorn

(L-5)

Transcend

- NorskaBlue (L-6)
gerryoat - Keyser Söze (L-6)
Eddie Cane - aronagrundy (L-6)

FireScreamer - Pants98

(L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch

Vote count 1.05

Dogwatch -

mozamis, Shadow_step

(L-5)

Shadow_Step

- Eddie Cane,

FireScreamer

(L-5)
Eddie Cane - aronagrundy,

Transcend

(L-5)
Keyser Soze -

Barleycorn

(L-6)
aronagrundy - gerryoat (L-6)

Transcend

- NorskaBlue (L-6)
gerryoat - Keyser Söze (L-6)

FireScreamer - Pants98

(L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

, DogWatch
[/countdown]

Vote count 1.06

Dogwatch -

mozamis, Shadow_step

(L-5)

Shadow_Step-

Eddie Cane,

FireScreamer

(L-5)

mozamis - Barleycorn, Transcend

(L-5)
Eddie Cane - aronagrundy (L-6)
aronagrundy - gerryoat (L-6)

Transcend

- NorskaBlue (L-6)
gerryoat - Keyser Söze (L-6)

FireScreamer - Pants98

(L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

, DogWatch

Vote count 1.07

FireScreamer - Pants98, Transcend

, DogWatch (L-4)

Shadow_Step

- Eddie Cane,

FireScreamer

(L-5)
gerryoat - Keyser Söze,

mozamis

(L-5)
Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

(L-6)

mozamis - Barleycorn

(L-6)
Eddie Cane - aronagrundy (L-6)
aronagrundy - gerryoat (L-6)

Transcend

- NorskaBlue (L-6)

Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

Vote count 1.08

FireScreamer - Pants98, Transcend

, DogWatch (L-4)

Shadow_Step

- Eddie Cane,

FireScreamer

(L-5)
gerryoat - Keyser Söze,

mozamis

(L-5)
Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

(L-6)

mozamis - Barleycorn

(L-6)
Eddie Cane - aronagrundy (L-6)
aronagrundy - gerryoat (L-6)

Transcend

- NorskaBlue (L-6)

Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

Vote count 1.09

FireScreamer - Pants98, Transcend

, DogWatch (L-4)
gerryoat - Keyser Söze,

mozamis

, aronagrundy (L-4)

Shadow_Step- Eddie Cane, FireScreamer (L-5)
Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

(L-6)

mozamis - Barleycorn

(L-6)

Transcend

- NorskaBlue (L-6)

Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

, gerryoat

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch

Vote count 1.09

mozamis - Barleycorn

, gerryoat, Eddie Cane, DogWatch (L-3)

FireScreamer - Transcend

(L-6)

Shadow_Step- FireScreamer

(L-6)
Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

(L-6)

Transcend

- NorskaBlue (L-6)
aronagrundy - Frankjaeger (L-6)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)
Gerryoat -

momo

Not Voting: Keyser Söze,

mozamis

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch

Vote count 1.10

momo - Barleycorn, Firescreamer

, gerryoat, DogWatch (L-3)

Dogwatch -

Shadow_step, mozamis

, Selynee (L-4)

FrankJaeger

- Eddie Cane,

momo, Transcend

(L-4)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)

Not Voting: Keyser Söze,

FrankJaeger

Vote count 1.11

momo - Barleycorn, Firescreamer

, gerryoat, DogWatch (L-3)[/b]
Dogwatch -

Shadow_step, mozamis

, Selynee (L-4)
FrankJaeger - Eddie Cane,

momo, Transcend

(L-4)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)

Not Voting: Keyser Söze,

FrankJaeger

Vote count 1.12

momo - Barleycorn, Firescreamer

, gerryoat, DogWatch (L-3)

Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

, Selynee (L-5)

FrankJaeger

- Eddie Cane,

momo, Transcend

(L-4)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)

Firescreamer - mozamis

(L-6)

Shadow_Step

- Keyser Soze (L-6)

Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

[/color]

Vote count 1.13

momo - Firescreamer

, gerryoat, DogWatch (L-4)
FrankJaeger - Eddie Cane,

momo, Transcend

(L-4)

Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

, Selynee (L-5)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)

Firescreamer - mozamis

(L-6)

Shadow_Step

- Keyser Soze (L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger, Barleycorn

Vote count 1.14

momo - Firescreamer

, gerryoat, DogWatch (L-4)

FrankJaeger

- Eddie Cane,

Transcend, momo

(L-4)

Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

, Selynee (L-5)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)

Firescreamer - mozamis

(L-6)

Shadow_Step

- Keyser Soze (L-6)

Not Voting:

FrankJaeger, Barleycorn

Vote count 1.15

momo - Firescreamer

, gerryoat, DogWatch (L-4)

FrankJaeger

- Eddie Cane,

Transcend, momo

(L-4)

Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

, Selynee (L-5)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)
Firescreamer -

mozamis

(L-6)

Shadow_Step

- Keyser Soze (L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger, Barleycorn

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch

Vote count 1.16

FrankJaeger

- Eddie Cane,

momo

, Keyser Soze,

Transcend

(L-3)

momo

- gerryoat, DogWatch (L-5)
Dogwatch - Shadow_step, Selynee (L-5)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)
Firescreamer -

mozamis

(L-6)

mozamis - Firescreamer

- (L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger, Barleycorn

[/color]

Vote count 1.17

FrankJaeger

- Eddie Cane,

momo

, Keyser Soze,

Transcend, mozamis

(L-2)

Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

, Selynee (L-5)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)

mozamis - Firescreamer

- (L-6)

momo

- DogWatch (L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger, Barleycorn

, gerryoat

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch

Day 1 ends in (expired on 2017-03-06 16:51:40)

Mod Note - Barleycorn is v/la until 3/5/2017
FrankJaeger has been prodded.
[/color]

Vote count 1.17

FrankJaeger

- Eddie Cane,

momo

, Keyser Soze,

Transcend, mozamis, Barleycorn

(L-1)

Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

, Selynee (L-5)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)

mozamis

-

Firescreamer

- (L-6)

momo

- DogWatch (L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

, gerryoat

Vote count FINAL

FrankJaeger

- Eddie Cane,

momo

, Keyser Soze,

mozamis, Barleycorn, Tramscend

, WhemeStar (LYNCHED)

Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

, Selynee (L-5)
mozamis -

Firescreamer

- (L-6)
momo - DogWatch (L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

, gerryoat

[/color]

I think I am starting to notice a pattern of voting behaviours. Here's the end of day 2. I'll finish analyzing day 2 tomorrow.

Spoiler: Final Vote Count from Day 2

Vote count Final

momo

- gerryoat, DogWatch,

FireScreamer, Boonskiies, Eddie Cane

, Keyser Soze(Lynched)
DogWatch - WhemeStar (L-5)
gerryoat -

momo

(L-5)

Not Voting:

Barleycorn

, & ThinkBig.

Right now I am interested in focusing on ISO'ing DogWatch

How are you coloring it? like, for example, fire and I are green in some of them but not all

[Eddie Cane]

shalom. tb, claim. gerry, i take that as a vt claim

[Eddie Cane]

Sorry I was not able to contribute much yesterday. I will be hopefully much more active today. Here is my first round of VCA. This is from day 1.

Spoiler: Day 1 vote counts

Vote count 1.03

aronagrundy - DogWatch, gerryoat (L-5)
Dogwatch -

mozamis

, Shadow_step (L-5)

Shadow_Step (Boonskiie's slot)

- Eddie Cane, FireScreamer (L-5)
Keyser Soze - Transcend,

Barleycorn

(L-5)

Transcend

- NorskaBlue (L-6)
gerryoat - Keyser Söze (L-6)
Eddie Cane - aronagrundy (L-6)

FireScreamer - Pants98 (Momo's slot)

(L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch

Vote count 1.04

aronagrundy - DogWatch, gerryoat (L-5)
Dogwatch -

mozamis

,

Shadow_step

(L-5)

Shadow_Step

- Eddie Cane, FireScreamer (L-5)
Keyser Soze -

Transcend, Barleycorn

(L-5)

Transcend

- NorskaBlue (L-6)
gerryoat - Keyser Söze (L-6)
Eddie Cane - aronagrundy (L-6)

FireScreamer - Pants98

(L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch

Vote count 1.05

Dogwatch -

mozamis, Shadow_step

(L-5)

Shadow_Step

- Eddie Cane,

FireScreamer

(L-5)
Eddie Cane - aronagrundy,

Transcend

(L-5)
Keyser Soze -

Barleycorn

(L-6)
aronagrundy - gerryoat (L-6)

Transcend

- NorskaBlue (L-6)
gerryoat - Keyser Söze (L-6)

FireScreamer - Pants98

(L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

, DogWatch
[/countdown]

Vote count 1.06

Dogwatch -

mozamis, Shadow_step

(L-5)

Shadow_Step-

Eddie Cane,

FireScreamer

(L-5)

mozamis - Barleycorn, Transcend

(L-5)
Eddie Cane - aronagrundy (L-6)
aronagrundy - gerryoat (L-6)

Transcend

- NorskaBlue (L-6)
gerryoat - Keyser Söze (L-6)

FireScreamer - Pants98

(L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

, DogWatch

Vote count 1.07

FireScreamer - Pants98, Transcend

, DogWatch (L-4)

Shadow_Step

- Eddie Cane,

FireScreamer

(L-5)
gerryoat - Keyser Söze,

mozamis

(L-5)
Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

(L-6)

mozamis - Barleycorn

(L-6)
Eddie Cane - aronagrundy (L-6)
aronagrundy - gerryoat (L-6)

Transcend

- NorskaBlue (L-6)

Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

Vote count 1.08

FireScreamer - Pants98, Transcend

, DogWatch (L-4)

Shadow_Step

- Eddie Cane,

FireScreamer

(L-5)
gerryoat - Keyser Söze,

mozamis

(L-5)
Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

(L-6)

mozamis - Barleycorn

(L-6)
Eddie Cane - aronagrundy (L-6)
aronagrundy - gerryoat (L-6)

Transcend

- NorskaBlue (L-6)

Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

Vote count 1.09

FireScreamer - Pants98, Transcend

, DogWatch (L-4)
gerryoat - Keyser Söze,

mozamis

, aronagrundy (L-4)

Shadow_Step- Eddie Cane, FireScreamer (L-5)
Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

(L-6)

mozamis - Barleycorn

(L-6)

Transcend

- NorskaBlue (L-6)

Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

, gerryoat

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch

Vote count 1.09

mozamis - Barleycorn

, gerryoat, Eddie Cane, DogWatch (L-3)

FireScreamer - Transcend

(L-6)

Shadow_Step- FireScreamer

(L-6)
Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

(L-6)

Transcend

- NorskaBlue (L-6)
aronagrundy - Frankjaeger (L-6)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)
Gerryoat -

momo

Not Voting: Keyser Söze,

mozamis

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch

Vote count 1.10

momo - Barleycorn, Firescreamer

, gerryoat, DogWatch (L-3)

Dogwatch -

Shadow_step, mozamis

, Selynee (L-4)

FrankJaeger

- Eddie Cane,

momo, Transcend

(L-4)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)

Not Voting: Keyser Söze,

FrankJaeger

Vote count 1.11

momo - Barleycorn, Firescreamer

, gerryoat, DogWatch (L-3)[/b]
Dogwatch -

Shadow_step, mozamis

, Selynee (L-4)
FrankJaeger - Eddie Cane,

momo, Transcend

(L-4)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)

Not Voting: Keyser Söze,

FrankJaeger

Vote count 1.12

momo - Barleycorn, Firescreamer

, gerryoat, DogWatch (L-3)

Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

, Selynee (L-5)

FrankJaeger

- Eddie Cane,

momo, Transcend

(L-4)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)

Firescreamer - mozamis

(L-6)

Shadow_Step

- Keyser Soze (L-6)

Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

[/color]

Vote count 1.13

momo - Firescreamer

, gerryoat, DogWatch (L-4)
FrankJaeger - Eddie Cane,

momo, Transcend

(L-4)

Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

, Selynee (L-5)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)

Firescreamer - mozamis

(L-6)

Shadow_Step

- Keyser Soze (L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger, Barleycorn

Vote count 1.14

momo - Firescreamer

, gerryoat, DogWatch (L-4)

FrankJaeger

- Eddie Cane,

Transcend, momo

(L-4)

Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

, Selynee (L-5)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)

Firescreamer - mozamis

(L-6)

Shadow_Step

- Keyser Soze (L-6)

Not Voting:

FrankJaeger, Barleycorn

Vote count 1.15

momo - Firescreamer

, gerryoat, DogWatch (L-4)

FrankJaeger

- Eddie Cane,

Transcend, momo

(L-4)

Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

, Selynee (L-5)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)
Firescreamer -

mozamis

(L-6)

Shadow_Step

- Keyser Soze (L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger, Barleycorn

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch

Vote count 1.16

FrankJaeger

- Eddie Cane,

momo

, Keyser Soze,

Transcend

(L-3)

momo

- gerryoat, DogWatch (L-5)
Dogwatch - Shadow_step, Selynee (L-5)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)
Firescreamer -

mozamis

(L-6)

mozamis - Firescreamer

- (L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger, Barleycorn

[/color]

Vote count 1.17

FrankJaeger

- Eddie Cane,

momo

, Keyser Soze,

Transcend, mozamis

(L-2)

Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

, Selynee (L-5)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)

mozamis - Firescreamer

- (L-6)

momo

- DogWatch (L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger, Barleycorn

, gerryoat

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch

Day 1 ends in (expired on 2017-03-06 16:51:40)

Mod Note - Barleycorn is v/la until 3/5/2017
FrankJaeger has been prodded.
[/color]

Vote count 1.17

FrankJaeger

- Eddie Cane,

momo

, Keyser Soze,

Transcend, mozamis, Barleycorn

(L-1)

Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

, Selynee (L-5)
Keyser Soze - Aronagrundy (L-6)

mozamis

-

Firescreamer

- (L-6)

momo

- DogWatch (L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

, gerryoat

Vote count FINAL

FrankJaeger

- Eddie Cane,

momo

, Keyser Soze,

mozamis, Barleycorn, Tramscend

, WhemeStar (LYNCHED)

Dogwatch -

Shadow_step

, Selynee (L-5)
mozamis -

Firescreamer

- (L-6)
momo - DogWatch (L-6)


Not Voting:

FrankJaeger

, gerryoat

[/color]

I think I am starting to notice a pattern of voting behaviours. Here's the end of day 2. I'll finish analyzing day 2 tomorrow.

Spoiler: Final Vote Count from Day 2

Vote count Final

momo

- gerryoat, DogWatch,

FireScreamer, Boonskiies, Eddie Cane

, Keyser Soze(Lynched)
DogWatch - WhemeStar (L-5)
gerryoat -

momo

(L-5)

Not Voting:

Barleycorn

, & ThinkBig.

Right now I am interested in focusing on ISO'ing DogWatch

How are you coloring it? like, for example, fire and I are green in some of them but not all

[Eddie Cane]

Intent to vote: WhemeStar

Today is MyLo and I assume we are dealing with a standard 10:3 team. Gerrygoat places a vote on WhemStar nearly 24 hours ago. If WS was town, the scum team would have almost certainly have quick hammered WS by now (assuming GG is town). Eddie Cane and KS have also not shown any signs at a quick hammer.

Occam's razor says that one of {Gerrygoat, Whemstar} is scum. I have a town lean on gerrygoat and so I think whemestar is probably scum.

8 ppl = 5 to lynch. IF scum is not in gerry wheme scum still can't hammer. bye bye weird argument

let's see the rest of your VCA explained and other catchup though that's more interesting

[Eddie Cane]

so who is mafs everyone?

'i'm not going to scum hunt mafs tee hee
and i'm going to make it look i don't cares'

keyset still scumreading gerry. i'll let you know when a townread develops.

bleh rereading this maybe arona(wheme) is scum. 252 is gross on its own. then arona actually ignores keyser's 347 (see 363 etc. where the eddie idea is completely dropped).

obviously can't ask arona about this, but why did you not follow up on 347 keyser?

369 looks like scum!arona trying to discredit town!keyser

376 looks like scum!arona backing off after town!keyser responds logically to his attempts to discredit. yet maintains "eh demagoguery is a thing"

fine gerry can be townish for 394 and maybe 387

ok i can get on board with scum!wheme. arona looks not good in these interactions. still would like to do more sorting.

what does the first line of this post mean

[Eddie Cane]

in the process of catching up, sorry.

are we still popcorn claiming? what happened to that?

we should.

wheme(already claimed)
gerry
tb
dog
fire
eddie
keyser

interesting you said fire was your most interested role and he's so low. especially based on your attitude towards him recently. wouldn't mind some justification but you're conftown so it's fine if you don't want to.

[Eddie Cane]

oh one issue with popcorn claiming is that there's a real possibility that not everyone gets to do it. i.e. if gerry is a lurkfuck for the rest of the dp we just don't get a massclaim

If someone stalls popcorn claiming that doesn't look good on them. even if you're busy I'd expect there's time to glance, paste your role, leave, especially since they don't need to name someome else removing any minor strat scum may have for strategically popcorning (ngl I don't know if there's an optimal strat or w.e)

[Eddie Cane]

Barley I haven't even been lurking. I've been posting this whole game while on VLA. You should be happy with that.

same.

[Eddie Cane]

I honestly forgot my role for this game lol. It says I'm mafia goon. That's PR right?

so who is mafs everyone?

'i'm not going to scum hunt mafs tee hee
and i'm going to make it look i don't cares'

i've already hardclaimed town. what more do u want

contradiction!!

[Eddie Cane]

I read through a gerry scum game and he tried a lot harder so idk

[Eddie Cane]

Frank hasnt posted in like 4 days lol. why are we wagoning him so hard right now? this is how yolo lynches happen and we lynch town. why not wait for him to get back and answer questions. then i can get a better idea on him

Frank hasnt posted in like 4 days lol. why are we wagoning him so hard right now? this is how yolo lynches happen and we lynch town. why not wait for him to get back and answer questions. then i can get a better idea on him

What makes momo different? like tell me why momo is scum but frank was town.

look at his last few posts. look at his response to claiming, that was by far the most town thing ive seen. sadly i wasnt around then.

I had frank as town and you guys lynched him soooooooo

see here's my issue with that: your only mention of frank was 842. we did wait for him to come back, he did claim. your only "defense" of him was basically implying he was null, and you didn't reply to any part of my case on him or anyone else's.then, AFTER he was lynched, you comment. maybe you were actually offline, maybe you weren't. let's say you were, I can understand that. what I don't understand what you want out of 1780 when scum defend town all the time and you didn't even do that.

[Eddie Cane]

vt

[Eddie Cane]

even night watcher makes sense. that said; I can't tell if it makes too much sense... does that make sense? like, I haven't played in a long time, I'm not sure if it's likely for even and odd night inspect roles to be partnered like that along with a follower.

barley or someone more experienced able to weigh in?

[Eddie Cane]

I believe it more than I disbelieve it so adding it to my town read on fire I accept it for now

[Eddie Cane]

Damn I was gonna fake claim even night watcher. Good thing I didnt! Lol.

Also I'm trying this game. I've outed my reads. I really don't see what I'm doing wrong.

I can't tell what the first line means (sarcasm because it's so specific, genuine, sarcasm because you believe it), clarify? this is an extension of asking how legitimate you find the claim, you're experienced and should be able to weigh in.

[Eddie Cane]

Hm 5 PRs seem a bit much, no?

is it not 4? or do you mean you the mafia goon pr

[Eddie Cane]

we don't even have the full setup yet lol

Even night watcher was so obvious that it could be fake.

this is basically where I'm at and barley the specific claim is why I'm questioning

depends gerry, some have a ton and some have a couple. almost all I've played have had protection of some sort (bg, jk, doc, etc) but idk I'm no setup wizard and this already seems pr heavy. let's see what Keyser and barley claim and go from there.

[Eddie Cane]

VOTE: wheem

GG WP

[Eddie Cane]

UNVOTE:
jk lol.

[Eddie Cane]

Intent to vote: WhemeStar

Today is MyLo and I assume we are dealing with a standard 10:3 team. Gerrygoat places a vote on WhemStar nearly 24 hours ago. If WS was town, the scum team would have almost certainly have quick hammered WS by now (assuming GG is town). Eddie Cane and KS have also not shown any signs at a quick hammer.

Occam's razor says that one of {Gerrygoat, Whemstar} is scum. I have a town lean on gerrygoat and so I think whemestar is probably scum.

This has been a few days ago and worth revisiting. The fact that Star wasn't hammered already is quite telling.

This post has already been disproven. Your logic is flawed and you voting me just proved this post

can we wagon think instead of wheme now

[Eddie Cane]

Yea

VOTE: thinkbig

bad catchup, never explained his VCA, making an outright false argument for why wheme is scum and then ignoring us and voting him, just garbage all around.

all this from a new player I might doubt it more than I do. ThinkBig is a player I respect and I know his town game is 10000% stronger than this. I already scumread his predecessor to ice the cake.

wheme might be scum. the quality of this means it could definitely be SvS. I am more confident in scum!ThinkBig so I say we flip him girst

[Eddie Cane]

VOTE: wheme

[Eddie Cane]

GG.

[Eddie Cane]

WOW THAT WAS FAST. I WENT TO GO GET FOOD NO

I don't usually like quick hammering tbh I'd have preferred a long drawn out dramatic epic ThinkBig lynch but whatever =p

[Eddie Cane]

Dude your vote was l-4

[Eddie Cane]

so there was no doc?

[Eddie Cane]

what was the full version?


thx for modding etc etc btw

[Eddie Cane]

I felt scum played really well, even you Dog.

Thanks Transcend, you're actually my favorite player on this site to watch, so I'm glad I could fool you.

agree with both (transcend is one of but not singular fav for me)

[Eddie Cane]

I felt like keyser should have totally been scum read. I felt his posts lack substance or feeing. But obviously I'm already biased

I would've scumread Keyser too i think and don't get why he was everyone's highest tr. but hey, it worked!

[Eddie Cane]

I have now played several times with momo and consider him a direct buff to scum, moz shot was awful no matter how you slice it, I think wheme and frank lynches could've been avoided though