Open 32 - Pick Your Poison Mafia (Game Over!), before 470

[Thin_Man]

vote mneme

[Thin_Man]

yep

[Thin_Man]

No

[Thin_Man]

Also, given my posts so far, I may try and only post in this game using either yes or no answers, just to see if it's possible to do so.

[Thin_Man]

unvote,vote:thin man

*wonders if that was a poorly concealed attempt to save dylan*

Missed this.

And it wasn't. If I was trying to build a counter wagon to Dylan, then it'd be pretty stupid of me not to actually put anything behind the counter-wagon, dooming it to miserable failure, surely?

[Thin_Man]

Pretty sure #205 was fairly blatantly not a yes/no. Keep up.

[Thin_Man]

Now get back on meneme.

[Thin_Man]

Well, you don't take much convincing.

[Thin_Man]

what in my predecessors performance convinced you then?

[Thin_Man]

right

[Thin_Man]

I think Thin_Man is a robot programmed to automatically respond with something short and not helpful as soon as someone else posts.

I am helpful. Helpful ol' TM, they call me back home.

[Thin_Man]

mneme sounds like scum trying to pretend to have genuine suspicions and failing

Can't disagree overmuch with this. It's almost like you selected the people who hadn't posted very much and the people who had attacked the dead people without actually thinking about whether they're actually scummy or not. That's fairly legitimate, I guess, but it's really lazy. I wouldn't mind knowing why he conveniently decided to vote for the one person on his list who was voting for him, or more specifically why he picked me over the other two.

Also, I reckon you're waay off re: rishi.

[Thin_Man]

Hi. Sorry, I've been fairly busy, and the past couple of days I've been quite ill. I've just posted in my other game, and I'll post in this one sometime tomorrow morning.

[Thin_Man]

Ok.

I agree with Jack regarding pretty much everything he posted regarding mneme, so I won't repeat that.

Re: Pat, twilight. Talking in twilight more common. I think the point about whether patrick is more likely to vent his frustration either way is weak. One thing I do dislike about it, though, is the fact it feels to me a little boilerplate, like a 'required townie response', just in the tone. That's just a feeling though.

@Shanba: You were fairly promising when you joined the site. Since then, though, you seem to have really dropped into mediocrity. It's a pity.

@Jdodge: Are you playing anything like you normally do as scum in this game? (genuine question)

I'm a little suspicious of JDodge, simply because he's usually active as town. But I've been wrong before.... *ahem*

Do you consider yourself stupid, then?

I was suspicious of Shanba when I replaced in (though to be far I was suspcious of nearly everyone when I replaced in, though I tend to remember my suspicions of experienced players more, for some reason). Seteals points are actually quite good, but there's something to shanba which I don't quite want to lynch yet. I would prefer Mneme at present, still by quite a way, though. That said, I'm also beginning to get annoyed by my lack of opinions regarding other people in the game. I can conclusively say my opinions regarding a few people in the game, but there are a lot that I can't, either because they just haven't been around enough for me to be happy reading them or simply because I just ain't done it yet. I'll try and remedy the second half.

[Thin_Man]

@Shanba: You were fairly promising when you joined the site. Since then, though, you seem to have really dropped into mediocrity. It's a pity.

/shrug. I've never been good as town. My strengths as a player are getting the guy I want lynched, and that's not so helpful when I'm suspecting the wrong player.

Well, if you're a lousy townie, is there any particular reason why I should be giving your opinions the time of day?

[Thin_Man]

Pretty sure the solution to this isn't for me to have to parse through your posts to find the things that are good amongst the substandard stuff, the solution is for you not to post the substandard stuff in the first place.

[Thin_Man]

@Jdodge: Are you playing anything like you normally do as scum in this game? (genuine question)

You do realize that I'm probably the last person you should ask about something like this, right?

Well, I think if anyone would know how you play as scum, it's you, and lying/misrepresenting regardless of your alignment is stupid, so I don't really see why you're a bad person to ask.

[Thin_Man]

Actually, I disagree. Posting self-analysis can be one of the hardest thigns to do as scum, as you have to not only invent your lies to explain your actions that have other motivations but also then keep your lies in order, and try and stop yourself contradicting earlier lies. Anything that makes scum commit to a lie is a good thing.

^^ this. (not that self-analysis is technically what I asked you to do, but it's probably a good thing as well, and the point holds across the two requests regardless.)

[Thin_Man]

Hi. I want to vote Jdodge, but there's something fairly large in his favour that I dislike.

[Thin_Man]

It's mostly the fact that he hammered mneme with so little of the deadline left. If I was scum, I would have just waited it out, considering mneme needed full majority to lynch. It's such a wifomy point in his favour that i despise trying to factor it in though.

[Thin_Man]

Why wouldn't you put much bias behind that?

Xyzzy is worthy of a bandwagon, I agree. I'll likely join it shortly.

[Thin_Man]

A simple plurality will lynch at that point.

Jdodge hammering had little effect on the outcome if we were near deadline...


I'd be surprised if xyzzy got replaced, he is active on the site. His prerogative, though.

oh. Well, ok then, that solves that moral conundrum.

[Thin_Man]

vote jdodge

[Thin_Man]

I see your points against Seteal, but I think Jdodge is a fair bit scummier, sorry.

Jack White and Rishi are blatantly town, Shanba I think has been acting generally town, and there was that last minute attack by Mneme to help it. I'm fairly confident Guardian is town.

I'm fairly confident the last 2 scum are within Patrick, Jdodge, Setael and Xyzzy.

[Thin_Man]

Ok, so my game's finally up and I have no other modding commitments.

It's 7:30am here and I'm rather drunk, so I won't post tonight. Soon as I wake up, though, I'll post in all the games I've been neglecting.

[Thin_Man]

Hmm. This will be a significant hurdle to my enjoyment of this game.

[Thin_Man]

I feel slightly less like an idiot now it turns out jdodge was scum as well.

My choices were Rishi/Jack/no-one (Thesp ended the night before I sent one for obvious reasons).