Open 27- Bird C9 (Game over!) before 466

[spectrumvoid]

vote: Aimee

Hi.

[spectrumvoid]

Frequent vote counts are good.

Hm... who's missing?

[spectrumvoid]

mod + everyone

Sorry... I was hospitalised for dengue fever and dehydration. I wanted to leave a note somewhere but my brother swears he couldn't post because he didn't register.

[spectrumvoid]

- I don't like how enlightened bystander placed a second vote, but I wouldn't mind giving some leeway since I think enlightened bystander is a newbie.

- I also find it odd that EB places fernando on his los, when he was also guilty of being away.

- Barmacal: I'm stepping in to defend barmacal more-or-less based on the same logic. He's a townperson (I mean the note under his username). Remarking about random voting seems pretty normal. I don't like how he bowed down to pressure, so I'm keeping a look out in future, but my verdict is not scummy for that scum-tell for now.

- About Fernando: The main case against him is lurking. He isn't the only one, myself included.

[spectrumvoid]

Tar's post 26 also comes across as being a little too aggressive. I don't see a need for Tar to place a vote, with his main case being not liking random voting = no lynch. However, whether or not this is scummy is questionable, because aggressiveness could be a playstyle.

[spectrumvoid]

Ryan:
Possibly the most notable issue is him going after Barmacral for random voting. His stated reason for the vote is for pressure. I'm pretty okay with this vote.

I don't like his 3rd post, where he 'frames' Barm --> says Barm is not intersted in scum hunting. Barm's original post says he doesn't think random voting furthers the game, and nowhere does he imply he's disinterested in scum hunting. In a twisted sense, I could argue the reverse, that Barm thinks because random voting is useless, we should get right down to scumhunting, ie, implying he wants to find out who is scum.

Post 4 shows ryan attacking Barm for contradiciting himself by random voting after saying he wasn't going to random vote. He was the first one to point this out, so this is plus points for ryan.

Post 7 confirms ryan thinks Barm is scum. This is consistent. I'll address Tarh later. He pokes inactive people, and followes up with a vote on fernando (said inactive).

He swings pretty much back and forth between barm and Fernando this game, with solid reasons. I see nothing wrong in his play.

[spectrumvoid]

Mokina:

There hasn't been anything that has happened for me to respond to at ALL.

I don't want to do the 2nd half of my assignment till tarh is around.

I see no point in doing a massive PBPA when we're at page 5.

[spectrumvoid]

Sharing things in mafia is a good idea.

Tarhalindur: Where's the 90& sure bit?

[spectrumvoid]

To clarify, I am NOT role fishing. I am asking this because I just did a brief summary of ryan in post 100, and I didn't come up with anything.

[spectrumvoid]

I don't see a case for ryan before TCS posted.

However, I see some weird interaction going on.
TCS posts, baits ryan to vote.
Ryan immediately follows with a vote on Tar.
If anyone reads through ryan's posts, you'll notice that most of his posts show suspicion on Fern instead.

Hence, if we buy the 'I'd be fine with voting for tar or fernando', why choose tarh?

[spectrumvoid]

Next question: Why choose tar to vote for, when you've mainly been going after fernando?

[spectrumvoid]

Erm...

unvote

I completely didn't realise my vote was still on due to my lack of activity earlier.

[spectrumvoid]

I know I'm town and have watched both of them try and place a case on me for awhile now with sketchy reasons at best. Tar's reasoning for voting me were pathetic and made it an easy vote to place on him. Either or is scum, and if you don't believe me, investigate me, I'm here to out the scum.

Let's look at ryan's response.

1. I know I'm town. O_o.
2. Investigate me.
3. It was easy to vote for Tar.

My first reaction was 2 = godfather, but this is an open game without one.
3 sounds like opportunistic voting. But then again, tar's vote was as opportunistic.

Couple of things before I vote: check out TCS. At this point, I'm leaning on TCS / mokina being pro-town, but I'll have another look. Also, I think tarhalindur and ryan both look scummy...

[spectrumvoid]

Hm... I don't really find anything bad per se about leading the town, provided the 'leader' is a good one.

However, I too don't like Aimee's requests. I'll state why: Aimee could be scum waiting to hear what the rest of us think, then echo some request and hop on a wagon.

[spectrumvoid]

My thoughts on ryan...

Let's look at ryan's response...

I think tarhalindur and ryan both look scummy...

[spectrumvoid]

Since you are way too lazy...

I know I'm town and have watched both of them try and place a case on me for awhile now with sketchy reasons at best. Tar's reasoning for voting me were pathetic and made it an easy vote to place on him. Either or is scum, and if you don't believe me, investigate me, I'm here to out the scum.

Let's look at ryan's response.

1. I know I'm town. O_o.
2. Investigate me.
3. It was easy to vote for Tar.

My first reaction was 2 = godfather, but this is an open game without one.
3 sounds like opportunistic voting. But then again, tar's vote was as opportunistic.

Couple of things before I vote: check out TCS. At this point, I'm leaning on TCS / mokina being pro-town, but I'll have another look. Also, I think tarhalindur and ryan both look scummy...

I made another post earlier about ryan. Go look it up.

[spectrumvoid]

Major attitude change: After a reread, because I've been inactive, I have now decided that I don't think ryan is scummy. I also do not think that TCS is scummy. As such, I will be voting tarha tomorrow.


(I have really bad internet connection because of school, I'll figure out a way tomorrow, post from library or something. If it gets really bad, I'll ask for replacement.)