Open 28 - Quack Mafia. OVER! But who won? before 466

[theopor_COD]

Hello all.

vote dral

[theopor_COD]

I'd rather look to agree on a claiming tactic discussion beforze going to lynch

Looks like someone's already been planning.

unvote, vote Hjallti

[theopor_COD]

Dral is by no means clear . . . everyone realises that right?

[theopor_COD]

You don't want a deadline warning, I hope.

Calm down dear, game's only just started . . .

unvote

vote Battle Mage

Seriously if there's a good place to hang your hat, it's on BM.

[theopor_COD]

BM - Do I need a reason? You know me well enougy by know - post, vote, watch for reactions, make a mental note etc.

[theopor_COD]

BM's latest posts give me a much better feeling.

unvote

Last night my dear friends I protected Jordan, as I guessed the majority of you would sling your coat tails on JDodge, Mert or Battle Mage.

[theopor_COD]

Jordan's an adequate decent player.

What do you find difficult to comprehend?

Plus BM I could just as easily be a quack or a Doc, I don't know yet - do any of us? No.

[theopor_COD]

BM - I don't know if I'm a quack or a Doc. Ideally I'd like to find out pronto . . . hence I don't want to protect someone who gets multiple protection etc. Catch my drift, maybe not but it's a WIFOM situation I guess.

If everyone protects an IC player (and yeh I'm peeved no-one protected me, bah) then we won't be able to ascertain much or who's lieing.

So far Mert's been protected by yourself, JDodge and Jordan - we don't know anything else from that aside from one of you being a clean Doc as he's still alive. I think, is that right?

So far no one else has claimed to have protected Jordan or Curious, they're both still alive so I'm feeling happy about the chances of being a proper Doc.

[theopor_COD]

All I'm saying is the argument for protecting lesser known players ahead of IC players - obviously there are 3 people in this little charade who are going to spin a web of lies and deceit but BM asked me why I protected Jordan so I responded to him.

I'm not clearing anyone. I'm not clearing Mert for protecting Curious or Dral for his so called quack protection on Fernando - I've already stated that back on Page 2. Obviously I'm clearing myself because I know my own alignment.

[theopor_COD]

Do we have everyone's protections yet?

[theopor_COD]

This is what I make of it all so far.

Alive
AmeliaLi - protected JDodge
curiouskarmadog - protected No One
theo - protected Jordan
Hjallti
Jordan - protected Mert
Indy - protected curiouskarmadog
Dral - protected Fernando
Mert - protected curiouskarmadog
JDodge - protected Mert
BM - protected Mert
ControlledBurn

Aimee is it worth me asking whether Fernando's protection would have worked on anyone? I'd guess usually it would so without him being able to tell us, cos he's dead obv we're still going to be none the wiser 100%.

[theopor_COD]

Sorry for a lack of posting my broadband at home is currently broke, awaiting BT repair. Hope to have it fixed by Friday.

[theopor_COD]

I'm back from my extended computer problems, re-reading.

[theopor_COD]

Ok we've got all the protections in, I've just scanned over the recent arguments, will reflect on them in greater detail tomorrow but I do think one of three who perched themselves onto Mert is a lieing scumbag or of course Mert's a scumbag himself and Fernando could have protected him aswell. Thanks to Hjallti I've got no idea over my ability . .

I don't think we can be certain of anything however as we don't know Fernando protected. I do however think the scum would prefer to be in a situation where it's harder for them to be tested as such, hence CKD's revelation of protecting no-one and the three who protected Mert appeal most to me at this stage, I think either way I'm pretty confused and it probably makes more sense to concentrate on other things such as the usual scumtells, lurking, lack of curiousity, defensiveness etc. Dral's recent post doesn't fill me with happy thoughts either.


This is for my own benefit for later on -
AmeliaLi - protected JDodge
curiouskarmadog - protected No One
theo - protected Jordan
Hjallti - protected Jordan
Jordan - protected Mert
Indy - protected curiouskarmadog
Dral - protected Fernando
Mert - protected curiouskarmadog
JDodge - protected Mert
BM - protected Mert
ControlledBurn - protected Hjallti

[theopor_COD]

EBWOP - BM snuck in a post similar to Dral whilst I was previewing, yeh maybe you two could find something to comment on instead of idling along awaiting someone to light the blue touch paper or even light it yourself.

[theopor_COD]

I believe he meant that reading the thread and not posting is scummy, implying that you're purposely not getting involved in conversation to avoid suspicion. It's borderline WIFOM in my opinion.

Disagree. Not getting involved is scummy. It's as if you've got something to hide. Posts like I'm here but have nothing to comment on rile me, as town make something happen, pressurize someone, prod poke etc. Otherwise we won't get anywhere.

Let's say we all decide to sit follow the thread and not do anything, the only people this favours is the scum.

Today has been hard to have a good reason to post in my opinion

Hard reason to post? You can join Dral and Battle Mage in the camp of willing but not able to promote discussion, at least with the Indy/Mert spat it got some juices flowing.

And whilst I'm on the warpath where is everyone else.

[theopor_COD]

I agree with everything here.

Classical scum trait. Agree with everything.

apart

from the targetting of people who protected you.

No surprise there, wouldn't want to cast suspicion on yourself eh. Jordan and JDodge clear in your eyes, BM? Three people target one person . . . chances are statistically wise one of them's probably a lieing scumbag. Ignoring them isn't the play for me.

Evidently, in a few days time, we will be able to learn alot from these people.
I'm more worried about people who targetted for weak reasoning, or chose not to target atall.
still need full reread.

We need to get people today, not in a few days time!!

Dral do not be downbeat, there's plenty of ways to catch scum out. Your appeal to emotion is one particular one and the lynch me comment. However I can't let BM fester anymore.

vote Battle Mage

[theopor_COD]

No you clown. It's the fact you automatically ignore Jordan and JDodge, when you say "apart from the people who protected Mert" . . . it's the word apart, obviously I don't expect anything but OMGUS when I attack you but it seems as if your giving JDodge and Jordan a free pass here.

[theopor_COD]

BM I'm not clearing anyone. The timing of the claims may be important aswell I need to go back and check who claimed protection first and what not . . .

[theopor_COD]

Nice work scum. Dissapointed to have dropped out due to my holiday but well done to the three of ya.