Mini 403: 101 MPH Mafia - Game Over

[scotmany12]

Why are we voting for pablito.

[scotmany12]

I'm not sure on who to vote yet. Right now, the only person I see that might be a little suspicous is Adele, but I think she had the town in mind. I'm also a little concerned with Shamrock's vote for Pablito, even though he did take it off. I'm undecided right now. I'm not that good at analyzing so I'm going to wait and see what turns up.

Also, I am able to be on everyday, but on weekdays I cannot get on till after 3:00 pm most of the time due to school. I hope that that isn't a problem.

[scotmany12]

Wow, a lot has happened since I last visited. I going to go read the two pages that I missed, and then I should be ready to make my vote.

[scotmany12]

I really was about to vote omg, just because I think he only has his well being in mind. Maybe its just a gut feeling, but I'm don't entirely trust him at this point.
So,

FoS: omg

However, I do agree with omg with Riverwind. He has made only one vote, and that was for Pablito. After that, he just seemed to fade away. I don't trust him either.

Vote: Riverwind

[scotmany12]

I still feel the same way about Riverwind. I just get a gut feeling that he iis scum. His vote for Pablito scared me, and he says he was hyper. Then he says hes has a life and can't be that active. To me, it looks like he is making up an exscuse to save himself. I think that he is panicking for having votes being put on him, and I don't like that one bit.

Also, omg, I am going to propose a hypothetical situation to you since you say that your survival is more important than anything else. Alright, you and another person are tied for a vote. You have yet voted, and the other person is a doctor. You, somehow, know for well that he is a doctor. Would you vote for him to svae yourself and risk a doctor being killed?

[scotmany12]

Also, for a little bit more evidence for Riverwind, at least in my eyes. His vote for omg comes off as a OMGUS vote, and I dislike those votes a lot.

[scotmany12]

I really didn't see how her plan would benefit us at all. In a game where the deadline can happen at any point, I don't think that her plan of keeping people at an even vote would benefit either town or mafia.

[scotmany12]

I think she had the town in mind, but I don't really know. Her plan isn't really evidence at all for me because I don't see it benefitting either side. Right now, I'm more concerned with River and omg.

[scotmany12]

Yamahako, whether he is doctor or not, there is really no point in lynching him today. That is too much of a risk. We cannot risk killing our own doctor. He will most likely be killed during the night, and if he is not, then we have a conflict. Right now though, its best for him to survive, and I don't know why you don't see that.

Unvote, Vote Yamahako

I'm going to sleep now. Also, why do I get the feeling that you dislike me omg.

[scotmany12]

All of these quotes will come from Yamahoko.

I wasn't advocating omg's lynch at any point

Oh really...

I'm 100% sure I'd like him to be lynched over Adele at this juncture.

I consider that advocating. Along with this

I still think OMG might be right lynch

This, however, is what gets me.

1 - no reason for the doc to claim when he did, if he was the real doc - however plenty of reasons for scum to claim doc in that situation (defense, people afraid to vote, make the real doc claim)

2 - risk of leaving him alive could be greater than risk of killing him. If he isn't killed durring the night, we are left with the same dillema today (and every day he's alive) potentially leading us to kill more townies, or leading to the death of more townies.

3 - he COULD be mafia, meaning we want to kill him anyway - just assuming he's a townie at this point is dangerous.

4 - a player so bad he claims doc on day one when he's not under any serious pressure wouldn't necessarily be effective in that role anyway - meaning we have little to lose by offing a "power role"

You not only said he had no reason to claim, which he actually did since he was on the copping blcok, plus you said it would be a greater risk in leaving him alive. How is that? If we kill him today, then we might kill off our doctor, which is never good. If he survives the night, then we might have to think about lynching him, but not now.

[scotmany12]

I could care less if omg voted for yamahako or not River. The reason I am voting for him is that he thinks that our best move is getting rid of someone who could be our doctor. You can say that I am defending omg, and that is fine, I kind of am. I still don't trust him fully though. If he survives the night, then I believe we have to look into him, not now though. The sole reason for me voting for yamahako is that he is willing to risk killing off our doctor.

[scotmany12]

No river, I don't really have another reason for voting Yamahako. I simply believe that someone who wants to risk killing a doctor is a big problem. omg is either doctor or scum in my mind(I haven't ruled him out being scum yet). In fact, this may just be another way for him to save himself. He said his survival is the most important to him, and he might have made up the claim to save himself. I still don't trust him, but I won't risk killing off a doctor. I guess Yamahako has a problem that I also saw in omg. He cares for himself, and not for the better of the town. That is why I am voting for him.

[scotmany12]

Yama, I think you pleaded your case for now, so

Unvote

. Kenji I'm not too sure about, and I really don't understand the case on ectomancer. Can someone explain that to me. Until now, I'm going back to my original vote.

Vote: Riverwind

[scotmany12]

How exactly do we know that you are a townie? So far, we don't know who anyone is.

[scotmany12]

I don't hate you river, and I honestly didn't recall you being in my other game. If I hated you then I would probably be voting for you in both games. Which I am not.

[scotmany12]

Actually, now that I looked back at the other thread, not one of my posts were directed at you.

[scotmany12]

The scummiest person, imo, when I read through was Scotmany12.

Vote:Scotmany12

His posts seem designed to slip under the radar and I get the impression that

he has no opinions of his own but is just trying to follow the flow of public opinion.

Yeah, except that I was the first one to vote for Riverwind, and then everyone jumped. So yeah, I see exactly where you are going.(That last sentence was sarcasm.)

[scotmany12]

In fact, the only time I think you can say that I followed opinion was when I voted for Yamahako. However, when I voted for him I was voting for him because I wanted to. Not because other people were doing it. So, yeah, you're logic on me makes no sense.

[scotmany12]

What reasoning is there for a Jack lynch? Did I miss something? Also, M4yhem. Yes I was on the riverwind lynch, but I was one of the first ones on. I know that that doesn't say much but still. Also, I'm a little confused on what you mena by me being "reasonable."

[scotmany12]

So we have two people claiming cops. This is big. As much as we need to focus on that, I think we are forgetting that omg claimed doc, and he was not killed. In my eyes, he is either doctor or scum. As I see it, there are three possible lynches for tonight. We can lynch one of the two "cops" or omg and see if he really is the doc.

[scotmany12]

I'm leaning to a jack vote, but I want to wait a little bit longer till I vote. I'm going to ben now. Goodnight everyone.

[scotmany12]

Wait, why is Adele guilty. I have to reread day 2 but I would like ot knoe why you think she is guilty.

[scotmany12]

Vote: Adele

Totally forgot you were cop. Sorry bout that.

[scotmany12]

How many scum do we think there is? If there is only two, then once we kill adele the game should be over, right?

[scotmany12]

Yeah, Jack, I'm not scum. Since you are cap, and yamahako is deputy, and mayhem is innocent, then we got three choices. Ecto, HD, and Kenji, unless I missed something and you had a read on one of them.

[scotmany12]

EBWOP

Since you are cop...

[scotmany12]

I don't think the roleblocker/nurse should claim. What if we lynch an innocent today then there is still a scum out there. If that person claims then there is just another person for the scum to kill, if we don't lynch the scum today. I have to go reread Mayhem's post right now.

[scotmany12]

After examining Mayhem's post, I have come to a decision.

Vote: M4yhem

[scotmany12]

I would actually want to know why you guys think I am scum. Disregard my vote on m4yhem and I would like to know why I appear scummy. I honestly think the last scum is either HD or m4yhem. I guess I did jump a little to soon on m4yhem, but I am just seeing scum in his post. He also was the last person to vote for adele. Why was he so reluctant? HD, however, did not vote for adele at all. M4yhem is also letting ecto off of the hook. We have no idea that he is a townie, and just because pablito wanted him lynched doesn't mean he isn't scum. I'm going to go look back in the topic now.

[scotmany12]

I'm actually going to

Unvote

For the first 6 pages or so it was between ectomancer and adele. Now one person was jumping between these two, and that is pablito. Not one of them seemed to be on the same page. Though I might be totally entirely wrong, I think that these three were focusing on each other so that it looks like they working together at all. If one was to be lynched, then the town would not expect another because of their little scuffle that they had on day 1. In fact, if adele was lynched day 1, ectomancer would look quite innocent, and it would depend on who pablito decided to vote for. They were playing us from the beginning, and made them look like enemies to each other. That is why I feel confident in my vote.

Vote: Ectomancer

[scotmany12]

I wanted you to disregard my vote for m4yhem because I wanted to see what you thought of me before i made that vote, because it didn't please you all very well. Yes I was on the riverwind lynch, I though he was truly scum. I was wrong. I though pablito was the cop, not you. I trusted him more, I was once again wrong. I never though there were 2 mafia. That question was an honest question, and I honestly did forget that you were cop. I don't see that as a scum tell.

[scotmany12]

Well, I have no defense for my vote on m4yhem. Maybe I like listening to cops, I don't know. I shouldn't have done it. But I recently looked back at the topic, and ecto jumped out at me. I was ruling him out before because of the conflict that he had on day 1, but as I see it now, those conflicts might have helped him, pablito, and adele. Not one of those agreed with another one during most of day 1. Both pablito and adele turned out to be scum. Maybe it is just a coincidence that ecto was thrown into that scuffle in day 1, but I think we should act on it as more than a coincidence.

[scotmany12]

Well since you guys aren't listening to me I have to do this now. I'm the nurse. If it wasn't for me, Jack would be dead right now. And now if we don't get the right pick today, I will most likely be killed. Really did not want to claim. Still think Ectomancer is the right pick here.

[scotmany12]

Ok.

Unvote, Vote: M4yhem

[scotmany12]

M4yhem, noone missed the deadline. I came back to check before the deadline was over the night and the day has started. I'm the nurse. I protected Jack. Still, I'm not entirely convinced on you being the godfather. Kenji, though most likely town, hasn't posted in a while and could be lurking. I still have suspicions on ecto, and HD I just don't know about. Maybe, possibly, there is not a deputy and yamahako is scum. All of these possibilities are flying through my head right now and I don't know which one seems more logical.

[scotmany12]

Yay, I'm still alive cause its scotmany12, not Scotmany12.

[scotmany12]

Um, if the town still wins, do I still win with them?

Mod edit : You're dead - Won't post who you win with in the game - Check your PM

[scotmany12]

Wow, I was right with ectomancer. Whether what I stated was really their plan, I was right that ecto was scum.