Night 1
Jabroni2000: Mafia RB - Block Alexander
Mini Neo: Mafia - kill Falcone
Nightfall: Mafia
Kenji: Serial Killer - kill Falcone
Alexander: Doc - Protect Mini Neo(blocked)
Kain McAdam: Back-up Doc
HezLucky: Cop - Investigate Nightfall (Mafia)
armlx: Vig -Hold
Silat: Watcher - Kain McAdam
Tyfo: Vanilla Townie
Falcone: Vanilla Townie (dead, dead)
outlaw: Vanilla Townie
Night 2
Jabroni2000: Mafia RB - Block Tyfo(fail)
Mini Neo: Mafia - kill Kenji
Nightfall: Mafia
Kenji: Serial Killer - kill armlx(dead)
Alexander: Doc - Protect Silat
HezLucky: Cop - Investigate Outlaw (Townie)
armlx: Vig - Hold(dead)
Silat: Watcher - armlx
Tyfo: Vanilla Townie
outlaw: Vanilla Townie
Night 3
Jabroni2000: Mafia RB - Miss
Mini Neo: Mafia - Miss
Alexander: Doc - Protect HezLucky
HezLucky: Cop - Investigate Mini Neo
Silat: Watcher - Tyfo
Tyfo: Vanilla Townie
outlaw: Vanilla Townie
Night 4
Jabroni2000: Mafia RB - Miss
Alexander: Doc - Protect HezLucky
HezLucky: Cop - Miss
Silat: Watcher - Alexander
Tyfo: Vanilla Townie
outlaw: Vanilla Townie
Night 4
Maz Madias: Mafia RB - No choice
Alexander: Doc - Protect HezLucky
HezLucky: Cop - Investigate Silat
Silat: Watcher - outlaw
outlaw: Vanilla Townie
Yeah, so it's pretty obvious that I messed this game up. Jabroni2000 should have been replaced the first time he missed his nightchoice, but he went on to miss another. Had those 2 kills gone through, plus had he roleblocked HezLucky, the mafia probably would have won.
But that brings me to my next mistake. This game was unbalanced to begin with. I figured I was giving the town a pretty good arsenal, with 2 investigative roles, a back-up for the doc, and a vig to counter claim the SK. Obviously it wasn't enough. Had the mafia not basically canceled out the SK, it could have gotten bad fast.
I originally had this slated to be Bad 90s Teen-Slasher Mafia, but the opportunity to mod a mini game on MTGSalvation opened up, and it was the only thing I had ready, so I used the idea for that game. Then when this came up, I had nothing prepared. I spent too much effort coming up with a theme for this game when I should have been worrying about balancing the set-up. Lesson learned.
Biggest apologies to Maz Medias, who was mostly screwed when he entered the game. I really didn't want to replace Jabroni due to the situation it would leave his replacement in, but it was the only thing I could do.
Once again, I apologize and hope you guys had fun anyway.