Open 167 - Pie E7 Game over, quick like. before 844

[Nikanor]

Sheesh, people!
Stop replacing out. It is dishonourable to your clan.
*rereading...*

[Nikanor]

Okay, I've read up and decided that we're not ready for a lynch yet.

I'm Vanilla Townie as well, and to Zach: I'm convinced that Haylen is scum

as well

What do you mean by, 'as well'?

@Netlava: You pointed out Toro's use of the word 'verify' regarding Haylen's claim as an incriminating tell against Toro. Why didn't you do the same for Jason when he used the word?

Also, I've said it a million times, I'll say it again.
Lurking is not a scumtell.
I don't see why Haylen is getting so much flak for this. Also, I've seen her lie about having a case as town before (it was pretty obvious to me that she was lying the whole time she said she had a case. Again, reference Newbie 800).

[Nikanor]

So my list so far is thus:
-Haylen: Neutralish, leaning scum for her iso 17, which seems OMGUS scummy to me.
-Toro: Neutral, he's blowing up the case against Haylen, but it at least seems genuine.
-Jason: Scummy. He was blowing up his points against Netlava early in the game, as well as misrepresenting him. I think that if we lynch Netlava and he flips scum, Jason will appear more town, and vice versa.
-Netlava: Scummy. Pushing a case against Toro without evidence, and unvoting him as soon as Toro makes his case, probably to see which way the town goes, to see if he has to bus his buddy Haylen. The fact that he points something out in the wording of Haylen's competing bandwagon (Toro) and not in the wording of other players just screams 'buddies with Haylen' to me.

[Nikanor]

Orly?
Well, I claim doctor.
The REAL doctor, not that fake Manzcar doctor.
He's just a phony.
A big, fat phony.
You and he are obviously scumpartners with Halyen.
Die scum.
Die.

Vote: Netlava.

[Nikanor]

To put it in Haiku form:
I am the doctor.
Please do not lynch me, sirrah!
Lynch Netlava please.

[Nikanor]

The lurking on behalf of CSL and KittyMo, I assume.

[Nikanor]

Yeah, same.
OH WELL.
(And I can't believe you guys are lynching the uncounterclaimed doc in an open game! What fools these mortals be!)

[Nikanor]

I can't believe I'm still alive....
I guess people are believing my claim!

[Nikanor]

Ouch, my skull. D:

[Nikanor]

DAMN, now I wish I didn't request to be replaced. Nikanor, you need to learn that THE GAME IS NOT OVER IF YOUR SCUMMATE IS DEAD!!! I've seen games where a lone scum has outwitted the whole town after his scummate was dead D1.

You've seen a game where one out of two scum is dead, and the cop has a guilty on the other scum, and the scum needs two mislynches to win, and the scum wins?
I applaud that person.

[Nikanor]

Yeah, if you hadn't investigated me, you would have been dead the next night.
I would've pushed for afatchic to be snaplynched after Netlava's claim.
I think I could have made a Jason lynch happen day three, but I'm not sure.
Just goes to show how powerful cop investigations are.

[Nikanor]

Sigh, I probably could've won if I hadn't been investigated!
Curse you, cops! Curse you! >:C

[Nikanor]

Claiming doc was funnier, and we lost either way.

[Nikanor]

Unless you think you could have pulled two mislynches out of nowhere by claiming cop? It's doubtful that even one mislynch would come of that, imo.

[Nikanor]

When the probability of victory is zero either way, I tend to go for the more amusing option.

[Nikanor]

I figured the person who replaced Zach was the best kill to make.
Toro: No, he claimed Townie.
Netlava: Easy to push a lynch against.
Jason: Had a chainlynch planned for him.
afatchic: Backup lynch. Lurking + Being on opposing bandwagon of scum = easy pickings.
Zach: No reason not to kill him. Plus, Manzcar is a fairly good player (even if I do get a horrible gut feeling from you ).

[Nikanor]

Yeah, I don't see that as a slip at all.
More like, 'I think she's scum so much that I'm really doubting she's a power role.'
If anything it's a bit of a scumtell.

[Nikanor]

Toro was pretty much obvtown to me after that lengthy rant. I was worried when I had to replace out that the scum would slink a lynch on him.

Eh, Toro was a claimed VT, and had things like investigation potential.
I would have tried to get Netlava lynched, if he hadn't hammered so quickly. :C

[Nikanor]

Manzcar, who did you protect? Obviously not yourself. Just curious.
CSL, you're saying you would have killed off the scummiest townie on N1?

[Nikanor]

Eh? Whose alt is that? (Probably Haylen's ).

[Nikanor]

Yeah, I blame our spot's loss on CSL in particular.
Not really. I think it was mostly bad luck that we got investigated for lurking for the rl issues and whatnot.

@KittyMo:
1) Haylen wasn't too obvscum. If anything, you could have bussed her, pushed for a Netlava/afatchic lynch on day two, then gone for a Jason lynch day three, like I was planning to do.
2) Agreed, but rl stuff gets in the way sometimes.
3) That's why you don't do the same stuff as scum every time, dummy. Be creative!
4) Meh, don't replace into a game you can't handle. Although that is part of Overeager Newbie Syndrome (ONS), I suppose.