Open 312 - Venomous Intentions [Game Over]

[lobstermania]

Vote: Vifam

because it looks pretty close to "wifom" and we don't need any of that.

[lobstermania]

I am having trouble following drmyshottyizsik's logic here. I'm also struggling to decide when/what to believe from him. I'm kind of confused.

[lobstermania]

Sorry, I'm traveling today, but hope to post when I get back home tonight.

[lobstermania]

So, now that it seems we're at a standstill with the shotty/muffin/andrew thing, is there anything else we can talk about? Otherwise I see this game going absolutely nowhere.

I completely agree. I'm struggling to find things worthy to comment on.

[lobstermania]

Unvote

. I like Vifam's play so far.
So what do we do now?

[lobstermania]

Vi is right. It's scummy to ask people NOT to post their speculations on scum. The only thing we could do at that point is randomly vote each other.

FoS: Shotty

I also agree with Xolelf that Shotty and Muffin are prime scum-suspects based on their play. But I'm still not sure about Andrew; he seems a bit confused about everything.

[lobstermania]

bro xofelf said that on jun 19 12 25pm
i voted him at jun 19 6 54pm
lobster said his stuff on jun 20 6 16 am
i saw xofelf first i voted her.

Bro, that's irrelevant. A player said something you perceived as scummy, so you voted for them. A different player said the same thing that you thought was scummy before, but you completely ignored them. At the very least, you should have commented on it if you really thought it was scummy, but you didn't. Extremely inconsistent.

Yeah, come on Andrew! Vote for me to prove you're town :-p

[lobstermania]

I know I've been kind of lurking so far, but I'm working on a post and will upload it tomorrow

[lobstermania]

Woops, I got caught up in my "weekend" and spaced on the game a little.

Thank you Mod for the extension!

I ask this question a lot and I always get pegged as scum for asking it, but what would be so bad with a no lynch on day one? Assuming the scum kill someone during the night, the numbers are still in our favor on Day Two: with 11 people alive, it would still take six to lynch. But if we mis-lynch on Day One, and scum kill Night One, then would take five to lynch on Day Two.

Most of the responses I get back are, "But even if we mis-lynch, at least we know that person is town. And now we can go back and re-read their posts knowing they were playing on our side." True, but we still didn't like what they had to say before we killed them.

The town doesn't seem bent to lynch anyone. Is there any other benefit to lynching on Day One when no one is particularly set on one?

[lobstermania]

I didn't like how Lobster contributed ZERO but comes out of nowhere and suggests a NL, I don't see how he's town, you guys will need to elaborate on that.

And yet a no lynch occurred and we were all fine.

I will admit that I'm not really good at this game. But I'm back and I will try harder to voice what I am thinking. I find it hard to search for and pick apart words in a post, so I asked a question to start a discussion. And then I started moving and forgot about the game. Thanks for not lynching me.
I agree that jilynne's play as been sub-par, but I need to go back and take a closer look before I vote.

[lobstermania]

@Lobster - Thoughts on Ejio?

I find eijolend to be one of the most pro-town players in this game. He has put a lot of thought and effort into his posts and votes. Plus, I agree with his reasoning on pretty much everything.

@Everyone - What is you read on BS? Who is your top pick?

I'm not sure how I feel about BS's RB claim. While it is nice to have prevented the loss of a PR, it is also the easiest of the three to claim. At this point in the game, though, I'm willing to let it rest.

jilynne1991 seems less like a mafia-player and more like a pokemon character going though puberty. I'm not sure if it's because she's new, or she just doesn't care, but she is all over the place. I would rather vote for drmyshottyizsik or andrew94 at the moment.

[lobstermania]

I really don't like how quickly the Day Two lynch got out of hand. Especially:

Vote Jil

I'm just following right now sorry, I may have to replace out soon.

Who hammers with the justification that he may be replaced? This is either scum or very poor sportsmanship.

[lobstermania]

Wait, I'm confused. How did we rule out a cop based on babyspice's role block? What if scum didn't send in a night kill to make it look like she blocked someone? What if babyspice faked the easiest PR to claim in the game and is actually scum?

Granted, it would make more sense if there were a doc. But again, we don't know who the scum tried to target. Did they target babyspice and the doc saved her? Or did they target someone else and get roleblocked? What if they targeted another person and the doc saved that person?
I think we still have a bit to discuss before we jump on babyspice's blocked role claim.

[lobstermania]

Thank you for further explaining that, llama. It makes a lot more sense to me now.
But we still can't confirm if babyspice actually role-blocked vifam, or if the doc successfully saved someone instead. Or both.

So where do we go from here?

[lobstermania]

So where do we go from here?

Where would you go? Are your thoughts still the same as last day?

I would still be up for a Drmyshotty lynch based on his overall play in the game. But I'm not sure how much I trust babyspice's claim. There are multiple ways to explain a no-kill. I'm stuck between voting someone else and seeing if babyspice can block another scum, or if we take her word and vote llama to see if she was right. Neither way is fool-proof

[lobstermania]

Sorry, I got distracted for a few days.

I've been really unimpressed with drmyshotty's play throughout this game. And while we were all pretty game to lynch jilynne, the his hammer vote really doesn't sit will with me.

Vote: drmyshottyizsik

[lobstermania]

Lobster and Vifam need to come back and vote someone here.

I am totally voting drmyshotty atm.
It was right after the vote count, but before you voted for Andrew....
....remember?

[lobstermania]

Seeing andrew/shotty/me are the most discussed for today, could everyone state whom they would be able to agree on, whom they'd rather not vote and are there any important outside wagons that we shouldn't overlook?

I'd prefer to see shotty get lynched (only two more votes!), but I would join the Andrew bandwagon if it came to it....

[lobstermania]

Someone come in here and hammer, we aren't no lynching twice.

This.

What about "This?" I agree with "This."

[lobstermania]

I'm so confused.....

[lobstermania]

I'm interested in hearing from Vifam.

Vote: Vifam

[lobstermania]

Vifam, you are really digging your own hole here by only posting that there is nothing to post about. Tell us what you think about the no kill from Night Two. Who are your scum reads? Do you really want Elli lynched? While I agree that he lacks any decent form of play, he's not as high up my scum list as Andrew or Mediocrejpop/shotty.