Open 205 - Medical Mafia - Game Over Too Soon?

[Light]

/confirm

[Light]

Agreed to some of mykonian's strat

However, i think we need to predict who the mafia are going to kill. Un-necessary losses will somewhat hurt our cause. We could essentially have 3 doctors die on us in one night, and that will greatly destroy our chances at winning.

[Light]

look, i believe that some of myko's strat is relevant, however it is somewhat flawed.

we definitely need a testing strat to test our doctor skills. I'd do the circle strat only if everyone else agrees to it, otherwise we could do a 'better variation of the idea'.

[Light]

hey guys. just finished reading (although only briefly skimmed through some) @_@

I don't have a better variation in mind, looker so i can't comment there.

After reading, i conclude that we should all go our separate ways for night 1. this circle thing proves to benefit the scum, and we don't want that do we? myko's 2nd and 3rd revisions aren't great either, there are still significant flaws in it.

Vote Count #3

mykonian (3) - Mindgamer, DiscoRoboto, XScorpion
XScorpion (2) - mykonian, SaintKerrigan
danny135 (1) - Looker

Not Voting (3) - danny135, Light, kyle99

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

[Light]

Im not lurking, i just don't check the forums as regularly as you guys do (24-48 hours?). If you can find evidence of me logging on and not posting at all in this thread, please, do show me.

saintkerrigan; i only agreed to some elements of myko's plan, not all of it. if you read back, you'll notice.

i switched to supporting the "everyman for himself strat" because between the two strats, the latter would be more advantageous for the town. Myko's plan (being highlighter by mindgame and others etc) is flawed because we could possibly kill 2 townies and have the scum kill freely.

" every man for himself " has advantages because of the following:
-You only know who you healed/killed/etc
-If nothing happens when you heal them, you'll be the only one to know
-There is a bigger chance of blocking scum's attack

discoroboto; fair enough, i don't trust you either. The only person i completely trust as of late is mindgamer, his posts indicate to me that he is definitely one of the townies.

kyle99: lol, don't talk about replacing me . the minimum i have to check is 72 hours? i check the forums atleast once every 48 hours.

!vote - no lynch

Only sus play so far is myko, with his circle, but i think that was him trying to contribute, so yeah.

-I need to ask this, but what is L-1? (Lynch 1?)

/end rant

[Light]

hey guys. just finished reading (although only briefly skimmed through some) @_@

I don't have a better variation in mind, looker so i can't comment there.

After reading, i conclude that we should all go our separate ways for night 1. this circle thing proves to benefit the scum, and we don't want that do we? myko's 2nd and 3rd revisions aren't great either, there are still significant flaws in it.

do you propose trying to protect the townies, or do you propose to kill the scum?

both if possible.

[Light]

my only suspect

was

myko, but his intentions were good.

@disco:
mindgamer is a definitely a townie because of two reasons:
-he points out the flaws in myko's plans, myko's plan would have given the scum a better chance at winning.
-he highlights to us that such a strat will damage our cause.
-I don't believe that a scum would be playing like he is now.

RE: Light's No-Lynch Vote
- I agree, Light's vote for a No-Lynch is not in the best interest of the town and I would advise him to unvote if he has no one he suspects. Votes=/= scumhunting.

yeh i have no suspects.

!unvote

[Light]

what do i think of xscorpion?

he is an intelligent poster, and obviously been playing mafia for awhile now, so i wouldn't think of dismissing any of his suggestions off the bat.

[Light]

mod: any word on replacement of danny?

He has about 20 hours from the time stamp on this post to pick up his prod and post.

myko's shift towards StK was a risky one at that. why are you now aiming StK? I guess avoiding answering a question would be abit "scummy" but it is well off confirming that they are really the scum.

[quote="MindGamer"]So you refuse to do a meta-read on SaintKerrigan, but in the mean time you have done a meta-read on Looker?[quote]

nice catch. There is absolutely nothing stopping you from searching for how StK plays. Asking for someone's weakness = complete stupidity. Its like saying "Lex: Oh hello there superman, what is your weakness?" "superman: kryptonite, it hurts me when i touch it or near it". No person who is not mentally f*cked in the head would tell you his/her weakness, unless of course you were good friends.

!vote myko

[Light]

looker just to let you know, this is my first game ever on mafiascum. don't bother searching me up. also, i believe mindgamer is town.

i've skimmed through the walls of text, pretty much read all of pg 6 (i think?), cannot comment till i actually finish reading them

@myko: ok it is true that i do not know the true meaning of "meta". however i assumed that it was some sort of profile look-up at someone's previous plays.

ok i get where your coming from, however i think that this entire town would never reveal their weaknesses if asked. this plan is flawed. I certainly wouldn't.

now it seems like disco is on the table, will be throughly reading tonight (or someone can just give me a break down of whats happened.)

[Light]

before i say anything: looker voted me? why? another pressure vote?

interesting turn of the table.

there is a disco bandwagon and a scorpion bandwagon. (1 for me to?)

@kyle what makes you vote scorpion to the extent that you would not lynch disco who has a 70% chance of being the scum (70% chance in my books)?

im not going to vote until kyle enlightens me as to why he believes that scorpion is the scum rather than disco. its obvious that i am eventually going to join 1 of the bandwagons, but i have yet to hear anything that suggests or screams to me that scorpion is scum.

unvote

[Light]

what? my responce to disco's bandwagon?

its now pretty obvious that disco is scum (well 70% sure), but why is there votes on xscorpion? is he more likely to be a scum than disco?

stk, so you would rather me stay on no vote for the rest of this day? is it bad that i join a bandwagon? i want an explanation on kyle as to why xscorpion lynch is better than a disco lynch. i don't do serious votes until i am absolutely sure that this is right. its up to kyle to tell me if its worth even lynching scorpion in the first place.

[Light]

you still haven't really answered my question, kyle, even if your mood has changed about xscorpion now, tell us why you were thinking that a xscorp lynch was a better option for you than a disco lynch?

70% sure is my way if saying that i am 'somewhat sure' disco is scum from his posts.

o no shit no1's gonna vote with you if you say 100%. No-one can ever be 100% sure on something. absolutely sure and 100% do not equal.

As i said before, this is my first time playing mafia on mafiascum. the no lynch was an acceptable way to say that you had no idea whos who on a different forum where i played mafia. i can't believe you guys are so anal about this. Because of your mood towards this, im either on no vote or actually pressuring someone.

do you not think my vote on myko was a pressure vote? i found his answer to me acceptable, which is what prompted no vote?

I wanted to know the exact reasons as to why you wanted xscorpion out rather than disco. im sure nearly every1 here wanted to know. There was already pressure being exerted onto disco, putting more is redundant. Even 1 vote on someone is enough to pressure them as to why they are doing this and that etc. There was enough pressure on disco already. So much that disco went into hyper-active mode and started posting more.

"I don't do serious votes until i am absolutely sure that this is right"
keyword is serious. there are two or more types of votes i see. pressure vote, serious vote (as in yeah there definitely scum), random vote (right im voting you to see what your gonna say because we have nothing right now etc), and not to sure vote (im going to lynch you, but there may be a chance that you really are a townie).

@stk - im asking him because so far, i have seen little to no scum activity from xscorpion at all. i wanted him to highlight to us what made him vote for him and what evidence he has of it.

[Light]

What is FoS?

could someone please give me a link with all the acronyms listed with their meanings etc?

@xscorpion why do you think kyle99 suspected you as one of the scum?

who are your current suspects?

What is your view on disco and stk?

[Light]

ahh k, thanks for the FoS definition.

I don't believe you have been lurking like crazy as kyle thinks you have been.

2. Looker? interesting. I would have thought looker was more pro-town to me. Maybe care to enlighten me with your reasonings behind suspecting looker?

3. I agree with both your views on the 2 users.

[Light]

and no vote.

i don't do serious votes until i am absolutely sure that this is right.

Im going to reread this thread to see if any1 has slipped up.

Vote Count #12

Light (2) - DiscoRoboto, kyle99
DiscoRoboto (2) - Mindgamer, mykonian
XScorpion (2) - Bio Hazard
Looker (1) - XScorpion
Mindgamer (1) - Looker
kyle99 (1) - SaintKerrigan

Not Voting (1) - Light

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

kyle99 has been prodded.

[Light]

[/color]*

I have no idea what you're talking about. ALTERNATIVELY: Thanks for shedding some

light

on that problem!
YEEEEEAAAAHHHH

thats in about 10 days. We really need to get the ball moving. Im going to re-analyse discoroboto's posts.

[Light]

Im sorry guys but i have some business to attend to in the next 48-72 hours.

please don't replace me.

@looker
give me more time. this business is serz.

[Light]

^i've been away sorry. I am now onboard

the voting deadline is today?

[Light]

WIFOM = ?

[Light]

was expected. i thought i would die to first day lynch.

anyways; completed a game on mafiscum; i need to skill up ;/