Open 195 - Vengeful Mafia - Game Over

[kunkstar7]

/confirmado.

[kunkstar7]

Vote:semioldguy

for not giving a random reason to vote for Annachie.

[kunkstar7]

Me giving a random fabricated reason for my vote wouldn't change the fact of who I am voting for. Even at random it's a coin flip as to whether I am right or not, it is good to see reactions to a vote rather than pittering around random or nonsensical reasons for early votes. So far I like where my vote is.

Also now having only three of the five of us currently active sucks.

True that it would not change your vote, but I find that discussion usually comes from one of these small little comments attached to the random vote, not just a vote in itself. By giving a small reason, regardless if it is random, allows the person in question something to react to.

[kunkstar7]

The "Zounds we made it to page two" vote count:

(1) Semioldguy:

Kunkstar7

(2) Animorpherv1:

Semioldguy, Mikeburnfire

(1) MikeBurnFire:

Animorpherv1

(0)Ellibereth
(1) Kunkstar7:

Ellibereth

With five players alive it takes three to lynch. The deadline is Feb. 4th.

I chose that reason because this discussion came up elsewhere a little before I made that post, so I felt that it was a good place to put my opinion in practice.

[kunkstar7]

Its in a currently ongoing game. What is the policy on discussing discussions that are in ongoing games?

[kunkstar7]

Did you initially have a scum pairing on Ellibereth and I? IF so, what lead you to such conclusion?

[kunkstar7]

He said that he was throwing it out the window, so I thought that he might have had that vibe to begin with.

[kunkstar7]

Yea mistake there, I'm definitely obvscum. Don't know about Elli though.

Has anyone ever actually claimed Mafia before?

[kunkstar7]

Yea when I saw Elli's vote I thought it was a hammer o_O, until I remembered the unvote. We have to be extra careful with such a small lynch majority.

[kunkstar7]

The "That page went a lot faster!" vote count:

(1) Semioldguy:

Kunkstar7

(2) Animorpherv1:

Semioldguy, Ellibereth

(0) MikeBurnFire:
(1)Ellibereth:

Mikeburnfire

(0) Kunkstar7

Not voting:

Animorpherv1

With five players alive it takes three to lynch. The deadline is Feb. 4th.

It would be a scum hammer I think he meant in that situation. It only takes one scum and one townie to allow the scumhammer.

[kunkstar7]

It would be a scum hammer I think he meant in that situation. It only takes one scum and one townie to allow the scumhammer.

He said that 1 lynches 4 and 4 shoots 1 and 1 flips town. That's a town hammer.

Oh ok, my misread.

[kunkstar7]

I'm not sure why I haven't touched on it. Ani's comment that led to Elli's vote didn't register as anything bad in my mind, as most of my games I have been viewed scummy, both town and scum, so I understood where he was coming from. That sentence is not a case you run to lynch with.

Yet Ellibereth was careful enough to make sure that it was not a hammer vote, and as you said yourself L-1's are going to be more common in this game. So basically no real reads on anyone in this game yet.

[kunkstar7]

I'm thinking kunk is the Godfather.

Any line of reason for this?

Although I did say I was obvscum. So I'm either the Godfather or Goon. Hm. Tough question.

[kunkstar7]

What specifically regarding my reaction?

[kunkstar7]

We are ready for a hammer?

Yes, I do believe that Ani's slip was scummy, if you were town you are not going to make a slip like that unless deliberately. Yet I think I'm still playing this like a standard 9p game, and asking for a hammer now seems weird.

[kunkstar7]

Vote: Animorpherv1

[kunkstar7]

@MBF:

Sure, will do.

I don't know why, as of yet, but I think Ellibereth's the goon. IMO, save the goon, look for the godfather. I think a godfather would be more discreet then that, considering that we lose if they get lynched.

Basically in my mind Ani's bussing his partner, but trying make it so we don't go after Elli. Ani as well only FOS'ed Elli early instead of voting, for "fear of a quickhammer", adding suspicion but not real pressure. Then Elli asking for the hammer is a continuation of this back and forth bussing.

Even in the attempt of bussing his partner he still tried protecting Elli with the "skip the goon, find the godfather" idea. I'm looking at Elli as the godfather.

[kunkstar7]

Sorry guys, should have been more assertive against Elli on Day 2. Thanks for modding ElectricBadger.