Not_Mafia
Battle_Mage
Gamma Emerald
Something_Smart
Dunnstral
Salsabil Faria
Save The Dragons
PenguinPower
PookytheMagicalBear
Almost50
Unfortunately I didn't get on it. Otherwise I would have unvoted to appease you.In post 54, implosion wrote:I expect everyone on my wagon to unvote me in their next posts.
In post 65, Scipio1 wrote:Tone of 52-54, I don't think scum expresses that they are town so outwardly like that.
In post 84, Dunnstral wrote:This read feels forcedIn post 65, Scipio1 wrote:Tone of 52-54, I don't think scum expresses that they are town so outwardly like that.
In post 99, Save The Dragons wrote:dragons if you're nasty
Is this a crumb PP is a green check?In post 103, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:p good p good
Well, I'll only accept that if HE says it. I ALWAYS SR you.In post 131, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:PP and I are masons
Sheesh! I totally forgot this was an Open setup.In post 132, implosion wrote:That role actually isn't in this setup, PookyTheMagicalBear!
Told you someone was gonna Town!bin me for it.In post 136, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:btw its a scumtell to look at the setup
ThisIn post 137, implosion wrote:Not only is that not true, I didn't even look at the setup! I just remembered it!
I'm allergic to that, and would rather have a regular burger. Thank you very much.In post 149, PenguinPower wrote:We were having a moment
Please don't. I would rather be null for now. TYVM.In post 160, implosion wrote:maybe a50 for town.
Why are you so persistent on spoiling the fun? You're in a game with PP, Pooky, and ME (and funnily enough this is the bottom trio on the players list). ENJOY THE RIDE.In post 165, implosion wrote:I'm begging for people to actually play this wonderful game of mafia we've found ourselves in!
I'd be SRing you myself if I wasn't familiar with your meta (of not posting much in early game). You should only suspect those who -you think- should be very familiar with your play and are still using your low activity as a reason to SR you. (FTR, you are NAI to me still)In post 323, Dunnstral wrote:There's three people "scumreading" me and I've barely posted
You guys can go ahead and town lock me
In post 333, Scipio1 wrote:@A50, why do you think people who post more are likely to be town? And vice versa?
I like to vote my TRs.In post 346, Save The Dragons wrote:...anyway.In post 327, Almost50 wrote:To be clear on how I read the game so far: PP/Pooky/implo/STD are all Town to me. IF I'm wrong then a max of ONE Scum in this group, but I'm leaning "None over One".
why is your vote still on pooky?
In post 360, Battle Mage wrote:Artemiana's ISO ain't great in the early going. Shading Pooky from the sidelines (when Pooky is looking town AF), unexplained vote on me when i was getting heat, and has already acknowledged finding it difficult to feign scumhunting.
VOTE: Artemiana
let's do this
In post 361, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:Cow Friend got my back
VOTE: Artemiana
time to make arrow girl walk the plank
I like their avatars.In post 365, Scipio1 wrote:What reads town to you from Penguin and STD?In post 334, Almost50 wrote:In post 333, Scipio1 wrote:@A50, why do you think people who post more are likely to be town? And vice versa?
It's not a general rule. I just think the onesin this gameare.
I either am or am not, but I am never maybe.In post 391, Not_Mafia wrote:We're all maybe scum, that's like, the whole point of the game
FTFYIn post 392, Something_Smart wrote:I'm sorry, I'll stop being a salty asshole andread when I get the opportunitywill try to be a sweet bum instead.
Some people say annyed people are easier to read than calm ones.In post 395, Something_Smart wrote:It probably wasn't on purpose. But it's still annoying.
+1In post 398, Not_Mafia wrote:Sometimes shitposting IS scumhunting
Not according to my unorthodox schemes. Mini is indeed one of the 1st 3 posters, with the other 2 being Dunn and PP. happen to TR PP, so it's -at least- a 40% chance Mini is Scum (seeing as I'm still Null on Dunn + it's only like 70% a chance that there is a scum player in the first 3 posters in any given game).In post 443, Something_Smart wrote:Scipio and STD feel town, and maybe implosion?
If I had to pick out a scumspect it would be Mini, but that's pretty minor.
In post 450, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:Let's play good cop bad cop.
Now you know the answer to your previous question. I did count scipio's vote. THAT is why I needed to explain that I did count.
Here's aIn post 533, implosion wrote:I don't especially like the Artemiana wagon but I am getting tired of waiting for her to do something, mostly because I still think when she does it'll be relatively fruitful to read off of.
Can I apply to this?? Please??In post 552, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:are you auditioning for the role of her defense attorney bro?
cuz like her present lawyer ain't doing much
Looks like sshe's going down fast. 24 hours ago she wasIn post 557, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:look it ain't up to me that Princess Artemiana has decided to give us the ghost.
In post 577, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:and a50 can be her defense attorney
In post 577, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:so a50 unvotes Her Majesty
In post 577, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:A50 realizes he's defending a baddie.
A50 rips off his lawyer suit and hammers Her Majesty - rejoins the Animal Police Department.
VOTE: implosionIn post 603, implosion wrote:I don't really see anything that looks like a crumb in Penguin's recent posting but I didn't look all that far back. It's entirely possible he'd hide behind N_M tbh.
EXACTLY! This is PROOF he didn't die hiding behind N_MIn post 604, Dunnstral wrote:Why did Penguin die on day 2 instead of night 1?
I fully agree. Mow vote this implosion guy with me as he is also crumbing traitor nowIn post 605, implosion wrote:I guess if the traitor wasn't recruited, then they're almost certainly offwagon, yeah? No reason to bus as a traitor with a 2-person scumteam.
And Dunn is responding. My solve is Dunn is the other Mafioso (main) and implo is the Traitor. Piece if cake.
I won't budge off implosion.In post 609, Dunnstral wrote:Salsabil Faria can easily be scum
I think we should take care of them and MiniMegabyte, I don't have a preference between the two
What do you mean? N_M died at night, PP died at the start of the day. The two did not die "simultaneously". I thought YOU should explain that as a member of the NRG.In post 614, Something_Smart wrote:Uh... Show your work?In post 611, Almost50 wrote:EXACTLY! This is PROOF he didn't die hiding behind N_M
ISO PP. He voted implo in RVS, was focused on him all day, and revoted him to reassert his crumb. He voted STD afterwards for a short period (which I don't think is the true crumb, but can't rule it out) and then he switched to Artimiana.In post 615, Something_Smart wrote:Show your work here too.In post 610, Almost50 wrote:PP hid behind implo or STD, and the former is much much more likely than the latter.
Well, I'm not voting you for now, am I?In post 618, Dunnstral wrote:There is little reason for main faction mafia to respond to a traitor signalIn post 613, Almost50 wrote:And Dunn is responding. My solve is Dunn is the other Mafioso (main) and implo is the Traitor. Piece if cake.
I'll reconsider if the mod confirms it's a mistake.In post 622, implosion wrote:I was assuming the "day two" thing was just a mistake and I don't understand why anyone thinks it isn't?
Hiding behind N_M without crumbing it would be much much worse play, don't you think? Like, you're a WEAK role and you don't crumb your target??In post 626, implosion wrote:N_M makes sense as a target; open 806 just ended where Penguin incorrectly townread N_M but his play this game IMO was a bit starkly different from that one (hence me saying I lightly townread him).
PP character. He even OUTED he was the Weak Hider when he promptly responded to Artimiana's fake claim with one word: Liar (tell me you didn't notice that too)In post 630, implosion wrote:based on...?In post 621, Almost50 wrote:and the way PP plays Weak Hider is NOT to try and survive, but rather as a one-shot Cop.
In a game with only 2 members for the main Scum team, AND a flipped Scum on D1???In post 632, Something_Smart wrote:News flash, hiders want to not visit scum. You do not hide behind a person you're scumreading. That's terrible play.
OK, so I am wrong, but I'm also stubborn. You solve the game, and I will keep my vote where I want it to be.In post 635, Something_Smart wrote:Didn't you just point out the "lying clodpole" thing as a potential N_M crumb?In post 631, Almost50 wrote:Hiding behind N_M without crumbing it would be much much worse play, don't you think?
I also disagree to that. This monkey is a shit player. Don't listen to him EVER.In post 636, Dunnstral wrote:I disagree that penguin crumbed that he was going to hide behind implosion
Are we distancing already?
Okie dokie. Now, one more question: Did he die hiding behind N_M??In post 645, Rockhopper wrote:In post 625, Almost50 wrote:I'll reconsider if the mod confirms it's a mistake.In post 622, implosion wrote:I was assuming the "day two" thing was just a mistake and I don't understand why anyone thinks it isn't?My bad for phrasing it like that. PP died on N1 and was found dead at the start of D2.
What do you mean "might"?? The setup explicitly does have a Traitor. 2 Goons + 1 Traitor is how the game starts.In post 734, implosion wrote:Remember there might be a traitor
Town starts with 2 guaranteed (unspecified) PRs. Mafia pick up to 3 modifiers and town gets as many additional PRs.In post 2, Rockhopper wrote:During pre-game, the Mafia Goons, Mafia Traitor, and Vanilla Townie roles are distributed to the playerlist. The Mafia have 24 hours to select any of the follow modifications to be applied to the team (up to three) assigning which Goon or Traitor gets the additional abilities. For each modification the Mafia select, an additional modification is granted to the town (up to three). Town can then be randomly given new roles, two plus additional roles granted by mafia (up to three for a max of five).
In this setup you can't recruit the Traitor in pre-game. You -instead- have the option of making one of the 2 Goons a Recruiter, and if the Recruiter shoots the Traitor they recruit them instead. (At least that's what I figured by reading the setup and comparing it to the originalIn post 734, implosion wrote:I'm not sure why S_S is acting like scum can't recruit the traitor? In my mind recruiting the traitor is the #1 powerup for scum to pick
implo, if you are town-aligned you are a town asset (at least in my own view), but before you try to form reads I urge you to go reread the setup we are in to understand it fully. Like, the Traitor is still a Traitor at this very moment is an essential difference between this setup and it's predecessor. The Traitor in this setup can only be recruited if shot by the Recruiter, and since we did have a NK then it's obvious the Recruiter -if exists- did not shoot the Traitor. There are no other killing roles in this setup (the original had the possibility of a Town Vig). I know these are some minor details but I think they're essential for you (or anyone else) to keep on mind still. Like this setup has a Neapolitan as opposed to a Goon Cop in Stack the Deck, so our investigative produces Inno's rather than guilties, and the inno's are solid (the clears of the Goon Cop are soft)In post 735, implosion wrote:Right now I'm inclined to townbin, roughly but not strongly in order of strength: Salsabil, Pooky, Battle Mage, STD, A50.