Scummies 2007 Nominations Closed!

[JDodge]

Pooky's Marathon Day record, from the stats I have (Bastard Mod games not counted):

8-0-1, Survived 6, NKd 2, Lynched 1, 3 Mafia Wins, 5 Town Wins.

[JDodge]

I don't really see the humor in that.

Also, any comedian could come to MS and post a comedy routine in General Discussion, would he deserve a Scummie then? I think Funniest Player should really be generally for things done in the game, not one liners.

I would agree. I'm not so sure I deserve an award for one small joke compared to the actually funny people.

[JDodge]

Seconded.

[JDodge]

Unthirded SV.

Nomination fight!

[JDodge]

I do think it's

declasse

to "unnominate" or oppose a nomination, though. Nominate someone you think is more deserving, or get out of the way, in my view.

I agree, but when the person who is

nominated

says it first, then I don't necessarily think it's as much of a problem.

[JDodge]

So if a person says "I suck at life, I should go kill myself", it's ok to say "Hey, you should go kill yourself"?

Where is it my right to interfere with what someone else wants to do, no matter what said action is?

EDIT: Just realized how much of an ass this makes me look like.

I

really

need to start thinking before I type.

[JDodge]

Best Original Musical?

[JDodge]

Second BM for most enjoyable - mini

[JDodge]

Harry Potter and the Unbalanced Game!

SPOILERS







HARRY IS THE SK

[JDodge]

Rename it to Flavor Text, to cover all?

[JDodge]

We need an equivalent of the Paragon for the mafia side of things.

[JDodge]

Nominate PJ for Best Mafia Performance here

Single handedly pretty much won it for the assasins.

I nominate MoS for Best Mafia Performance for that game, he did a great job of handing the game to the scum

[JDodge]

Mr Sroofer, I apologize but:

Nominate Kelly Chen for Best Setup for:
Assassins in the Palace

&

Nominate Kelly Chen for Best Setup for:
Crush Nightless

Third both

Nominate Shanba for best newbie

if we are to have that award

[JDodge]

I'd like to nominate Mastermind of Sin as "Worst Overall Scummer" due to his performances across mafiascum all the fucking time

Second

[JDodge]

Third Flameaxe

[JDodge]

Do you have the shortest day for Open.

Vengeful hit a lynch in four posts, the votes for which came in over a 2 minute span, four minutes after the day started.

And interestingly enough it's still ongoing if you would ever so kindly shut up about it

[JDodge]

Why don't we rename this thread "COME TALK ABOUT ONGOING GAMES HERE!!!!!!"

[JDodge]

Is there an award for "Most likely to be Lynched Day 1"?, because I deserve it. Infinite times to the third. I think I've been lynched on the first day in a game 4 or 5 times.

That would be rewarding poor play, something we don't usually do

[JDodge]

Mr. Grey also ran Verbose Mafia 2, and will presumably be running the other two parts of the California trilogy sometime in the future.

Also, "London Mod" won Best Night Scene Writer in 2005, for Cadmium and Leonidas.

And Mr. Grey has it currently. I don't see why this is at all an issue when the answer is obvious to anyone who has looked at the game in question.

[JDodge]

Pooky's got to be up for some sort of award for his record during the Marathon games... something like 9-1 (and the "loss" was really a draw).

If there is some kind of Miscellaneous Award,

Nominate Skruffs for his invention of that legendary setup which i forget the name of, but when 1 player is lynched, they choose who dies next.

In light of this, I would like to

nominate that person for that thing in that game where people were lynched and people died

.

[JDodge]

Nominate Seol for best contribution to MD