Scummies 2015 - Nomination Thread!

[VysePresident]

6th Mod Error

Magua for Site Overlord!

[VysePresident]

Nominating Plotinus for

Rising Star

&

Best Replacement

for her performance in We Didn't Playtest This Mafia

I can't really do her play justice, but I'll try. For a newbie, and really, for anyone, she put an incredible amount of effort into the game. She replaced into an essentially dead Town slot & immediately started to Obv-Town herself & saved a slot that was almost a default lynch earlier in the phase. She went on to read through the entire, 100+ page thread, analyzing her thoughts in thread, and in the process, caught onto two scum who were widely Townread at that point.

When voted in 3-man LyLo by the other Townie, she correctly recognized which one was scum, and managed to talk the Townie down from their vote, rather than countervoting & ensuring a loss. Even though the other Townie ultimately chose to lynch her, it was almost entirely a matter of setup spec over play. The sheer dedication & quality of play here was just amazing.

Plot's got a heck of a lot of potential, and I highly look forward to watching her grow.

[VysePresident]

Kodak moment for voided for continuing to play even on end game

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... start=4925

4th

That's the funniest thing i've seen.

5th. :,)

[VysePresident]

We actually had a ton of seconds already, right after my post. Not sure why they have none down.

But yeah, Plot definitely earned it.

[VysePresident]

Nomming Plot for: Everything

Let's just save time.

(but seriously,

Nth Plot for Moderation.

This would be me hydra-slipping.

[VysePresident]

For what it's worth Drixx, if there was a scummie for individual gameplay, I'd have nominated you after SMITE. I wasn't particularly comfortable nominating the rest of your team for obvious reasons, and wasn't entirely sure if it was appropriate for the body of work award. In the end, I decided it probably wasn't even my place to do so, and decided to just watch you in future games we might be in together.

Beyond that, my thought on self-nominations is that the place they're in is about the best it can be. There may occasionally be valid reasons for a self-nom, but they'd better be good if I'm not just going to roll my eyes at someone's ego.

[VysePresident]

I think Kodak moment might be more appropriate?

I haven't had time to check the thread, so it could be really genius play on his part that deserves 3rd party nom, but I'm just asking?

[VysePresident]

I'm of the opinion that one should nth any particularly good example, and let the judges sort it out.

[VysePresident]

Nth Varsoon

I've never been in his games, but I remember I've had him down as a mod I'd love to play under sometime, when I stop being such a mess.

[VysePresident]

Eh, sure.

Nthing Drixx

[VysePresident]

I guess I'll do this myself if this is a thing?

not a thing

Sorry. I was trying to be helpful so that the group of people who do the evaluating don't have to do a bunch of extra work. I figured a brief summary of my body of work as scum for the year, with links to what is worth looking at would be useful and helpful. Wasn't at all intending to trespass on any spoken or unspoken ground that shouldn't be trespassed upon.

Drixx, you are a more melancholic version of me, when I'm not acting like I actually know what I'm doing in life.

In other words, don't sweat it dude. I was actually kinda interested, and it wasn't too gratingly egocentric or anything.