NorwegianboyEE's Mini Normal Review, April 2022

[mastina]

Definitely townsided--the Vengeful might need to die to use the kill but is still an incredibly strong town role since Vengefuls are a town-only role and that is a town-controlled kill and millers are often townread anyway. Cop is a full investigative; IC is a free innocent. Then, the mafia rolecop is delayed for a night with the traitor weakening the scumteam further.

As an aside, I don't think the setup makes a lot of guessing be involved. It's definitely a traitor comp, but the town has too much for a traitor comp and the roles don't have much guessing involved.

[mastina]

Definitely a much better start; I want Ircher to gutcheck me on 6 being good tho.

[mastina]

Balance-wise I think it's fine.

Which means need roles/rules/result PMs/etc.

[mastina]

We still need the typed out results anyway.

[mastina]

Neighborizer doesn't get a result from a failure, but investigative roles do.

I'm not comfortable with a pass before I see full clarity in those results.

Investigative roles are told on a failure, explicitly, their action failed and as a result, they get No Result.

The Neighborizer, however, receives no feedback at all, not even a PM.

[mastina]

Is there a wiki page that states this so clearly or are we just supposed to know this beforehand.

Well this article is a bit of a stub, but it contains the general rules.

As for the specifics, they're listed on the Normal Guidelines section of each role.

For instance, the rule for No Result is listed here for a cop;
The rule for No Result is listed here for a tracker;
Many roles like Doctor list the fact that they do not receive a result (altho admittedly some of them, including Neighborizer, admittedly don't).

[mastina]

I think that is everything needed for a pass.