Blitz 2: The Stars My Destination Mafia- GAME OVER!

[Huntress]

/confirm

[Huntress]

* winces at the all-caps *

VOTE: BBmolla

You are oooold school. When did you come back to the site?

I came back over three years ago, after a two year break, but you've played with me a couple of times since then.

[Huntress]

What changed your mind?

Changed my mind from what? That was my first post apart from the confirm.

[Huntress]

You want me to vote him, you need to tell me why.

[Huntress]

This is fairly accurate.

I can elaborate after I get off work, if you prefer.

Please do.

[Huntress]

@ Syryana:

Thanks for the elaboration in 106. The problem I have with it though is that it seems to me you are taking each of Firebringer's posts and finding a reason for it to be scummy, which is scummy in itself.

I have a question for you: Do you think Nosferatu misunderstood what Firebringer meant about a possible scum on the wagon in his reply to Spiffeh (61)?

Vote: Syryana

[Huntress]

I want you to be scum, I'm gonna ride this out for now but I'll switch to Nos if it happens. Maybe he's SK and you're Mafia.

Why might Nos be SK rather than town, or mafia to Fb town? Or even in different scumgroups come to that? To say SK seems oddly specific.

[Huntress]

@ Nosferatu:

Why are you responding to a post that was addressed to someone else?

[Huntress]

What you did by answering that was to deny BBmolla the chance to give his reply without it being clear that the response was his and his alone, thereby muddying the waters some, and affects the effectiveness of the question and how I judge the reply.

In other words you are interfering with my scumhunting which is anti-town at best and scummy at worst.

In this particular case I don't think much damage was done as you appear to have missed the point of my post but in future please wait until a question has been answered before adding your own take on it.

Now I'd like you to explain what you thought was scummy about my post.

[Huntress]

Catching up in a couple of hours.

[Huntress]

I hate it when stuff starts blowing up when I'm trying to catch up.

Unvote

for now in view of the claims.

@ Syryana:

Thanks for the elaboration in 106. The problem I have with it though is that it seems to me you are taking each of Firebringer's posts and finding a reason for it to be scummy, which is scummy in itself.

I have a question for you: Do you think Nosferatu misunderstood what Firebringer meant about a possible scum on the wagon in his reply to Spiffeh (61)?

No I'm not. Where am I doing this?

Re Nos: I don't think so, and I have no idea what the point of that question is.

In 106, instead of taking Fb's statements at face value you were putting your own slant on them then calling them scummy.

The point of my question was that you were attacking Fb for not responding to Nos's question when he actually had answered it, but you ignored that even though you quoted the answer.

You asked what I perceived as a loaded question. You left out the context making the question seem really suspicious, and whatever answer given would just lead to "well why sk of all things" and further suspicion.

if me and fire aren't in the same scum team and we're both scummy, then a logical conclusion would be that one of us is sk and the other is mafia. The number of players makes more than one team unlikely.

Nope; it was a straight question to BBmolla about his idea of the setup, and didn't have anything to do with you or Fb really.

[Huntress]

What I want is people to explicitly say "I believe two roleblocking town players is plausible" before they opt for another lynch.

Mini 739 had two town Jailkeepers and a mafia roleblocker. It's probably quite rare though.

[Huntress]

Roleblocker/Jailkeepers are uncommon due to awkward role interaction Talah.

A roleblocker blocks a jailkeeper who protect/roleblocks the roleblocker. The roleblocker is nightkilled. How does this resolve?

roleblocker dies. Emergency breakdown of Golden Rule - Block > Jailkeep > Kill. The jailkeeper will be blocked, and the kill will go through.

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?tit ... ormal_Game

Not that hard guys.

That only applies if the mod is using NAR, otherwise they are resolved however the mod has planned beforehand.

[Huntress]

Not all the mods here use NAR. It depends on personal preference, balance, design etc. It's always best to check with the mod if you need to know, rather than just making assumptions.

Vote: Ranger

because I don't want to lynch either DGB or Syryana toDay. Would also consider voting talah but there are no votes on that wagon at the moment. I don't think there is anyone else I'm ready to vote just now.

[Huntress]

Why vote on a wagon that has a scumread of yours on it? Why is Ranger scum? What do you think of Kid A?

Why not? It's not a strong scum read.

Ranger is scummy for the way he completely identified with Syryana's reasons for voting Firebringer, even though they were flawed. Again, it's not a strong read but it's the best I've got at the moment.

I thought the way Kid A came out in support of DGB was more town than scum.

[Huntress]

Ranger is scummy for the way she completely identified with Syryana's reasons for voting Firebringer, even though they were flawed. Again, it's not a strong read but it's the best I've got at the moment.

I'm confused by this logic. Shouldn't Molla be objectively scummier than Ranger, as I read his mind by his own admission?

Why? Molla posted his reasons for suspecting Fb before you did, besides which I get a town vibe from him.

[Huntress]

@ Spiffeh:

You could always switch to Ranger.

[Huntress]

Congrats, town! Thanks for the game, Ffery.