Newbie 992 - Game Over

[Alduskkel]

Tangion (2) - Trick r Treat, andrew94
Chimp Pants (2) - Sauron, Ythan
Robbnva (1) - Tazaro
Trick r Treat (1) - Chimp Pants

Not Voting (3) - caelum, Tangion, Robbnva

With 9 alive it is 5 to lynch.

[Ythan]

I'm reading. You are neither pursuing any pro-town ends nor answering simple questions.

[Chimp Pants]

Are you saying my actions are pro-scum? How so? And yes, I answered your question twice. Here's a third time: How could Robbnva defend Tazaro at night from Trick r Treat?

[andrew94]

i vote him to show him what policy lynch is

[Ythan]

I'm saying exactly what I said in my previous post. Additionally, you have still offered no explanation of how it was rolefishing. If you think you have then you are misunderstanding something crucial. If you're just lying then enjoy my vote.

[Chimp Pants]

Andrew: How does one vote show what a policy lynch is?

[Chimp Pants]

Ythan: What am I misunderstanding?

[Ythan]

I don't know what you're not getting. But what you have done is not answer my simple question. What do you think rolefishing is?

[Chimp Pants]

I know what role fishing is. Wow....

Please answer these.
How could Robbnva defend Tazaro at night from Trick r Treat?
What information could scum-Tazaro gain from PR-townie by his request?

[Ythan]

No I asked what you think it is. And how do you think that his asking a doc to defend him (not to out themselves in any way) is rolefishing?

[Chimp Pants]

So you won't answer my questions?

[Ythan]

Won't you answer mine? I at least cut to the root of your foolish questions and addressed the real matters at hand. All you're doing is, well, nothing.

[Robbnva]

Why are you defending Tazaro?

how is saying a player has a similiar style to myself, defending him?

[Ythan]

Why are you defending Tazaro?

how is saying a player has a similiar style to myself, defending him?

I believe that your intent was to defend him.

[Robbnva]

ok well it wasn't.

anyway, this debate between you and Chimp is very interesting to say the least, Chimp is acting strange but right now andrew's vote seems odd

vote andrew

[Ythan]

Odd in what way?

[Tazaro]

Tazaro:

Vote: Robbnva
For unnecessary defense. Though, if that Trick r Treat appears in my window at night, defend me for real.

Why are you role fishing?

"Defend me for real" is talking about an outside-of-game context.
Oh, and stop taking my schtick, Chimp Pants. Nobody is supposed to be scummier than me. It's my playstyle.

[Tazaro]

In fact, scummier than me is too scummy
Unvote: Robbnva
Vote: Chimp Pants. Bandwaggon.

[Robbnva]

Odd in what way?

odd in that it didn't make any sense to vote and claim it was a policy lynch

[Tazaro]

i vote him to show him what policy lynch is

What was the policy against Tangion?

[Tazaro]

You can't do a policy lynch without making clear the policy, andrew94.

[Trick r Treat]

Unvote
Vote: Chimp Pants

You're player scummier than every other player on here combined and that's saying something.

[Sauron]

Sauron: Is this a random vote accompanied by a comment about shortening the RVS?

No. It is a non-random vote accompanied by a comment saying that we quickly moved to the point where we should be doing more than random votes. I was calling you out for continuing random votes when I felt you could have done better.

Ythan: I just checked your wiki. You've never won a newbie game as scum and have a losing record as town. Does that mean that it would be pro-town for you to self hammer?

Hmm... seems my vote was well-placed. Care to tell us in what world this quote makes any sense?

Why are you role fishing?

So... how was that role-fishing? It's one thing for Taz to start asking questions about who's a PR or making observations pointing out who looks doc-ish, but it's an entirely different thing to make a joke about wanting a hypothetical doc to save him in the night if he's being targeted by Mafia. So, please, explicitly explain how Taz was rolefishing.

Unvote
Vote: Chimp Pants

You're player scummier than every other player on here combined and that's saying something.

I believe this one puts us at L-1, so people should be aware of this before hopping on the Chimp wagon.

@Tazaro:
We talked about this in 943. Can you please try to condense your thoughts into one moderately sized post rather than a quick succession of short posts? It's much easier for the rest of us in game that way.

[Tazaro]

Sauron: Is this a random vote accompanied by a comment about shortening the RVS?

No. It is a non-random vote accompanied by a comment saying that we quickly moved to the point where we should be doing more than random votes. I was calling you out for continuing random votes when I felt you could have done better.

I believe Chimp Pants was referring to his vote on Trick r Treat when he said "this." You accused him of wanting to shorten the RVS. And Chimp Pants is asking "Did I really say I wanted the RVS to be shortened?" Am I condensing my thoughts right?

[Chimp Pants]

So, please, explicitly explain how Taz was rolefishing.

Have you ever been fishing? Fish don't just hop in the boat unless its a really awesome boat. I'm not interested in making up crazy scenarios about imagined scum actions, but really, no one sees how townies (particularly newbtownies) could respond to that joke and give a hint about being a power role (or VT)? Responding to that joke could easily give clues as to alignment. Rolefishing must contain explicit questions about who's a power role? Fish don't clean and cook themselves. There's lots of steps before yummy goodness.

Hmm... seems my vote was well-placed. Care to tell us in what world this quote makes any sense?

It was a half joke/half question to feel out the IC. With Ythan's previous comment about using policy lynches to discourage future anti-town behavior (I'll gladly pay you Tuesday for a hamburger today), I thought I needed a little further insight into his thought process.

You're player scummier than every other player on here combined and that's saying something.

What about my play suggests alignment? Also, who else do you find scummy?

I believe Chimp Pants was referring to his vote on Trick r Treat when he said "this." You accused him of wanting to shorten the RVS. And Chimp Pants is asking "Did I really say I wanted the RVS to be shortened?" Am I condensing my thoughts right?

I was referencing Sauron's vote for me and subsequent statement in favor of shortening the RVS.

@Ythan: I'm still waiting for answers to my questions.