Day one notes:
-Still not liking that Esp
knew
Nobody was town.
-Also just noticing Mallows post
mallowgeno wrote:I can never get a good read on ICs because they devote themselves to helping everyone which may lure newbies into a reading them as town. I'm not saying you're mafia Espeonage, I'm just saying that if you are, you won't fool me.
which to me sounds like "I'm gonna act like I'll always be suspicious of you, but I really won't do much about it." I'm thinking this could be a form of the Vote:town Fos:scum buddy theory. Mallow later votes for Esp, but no one else is so it was a safe vote to try and distance scum buddies.
-I like the way Trendall posts his defenses. They're clear and seem genuine. But I don't see much offense until he attacks Nobody, which is what everyone was doing. Not that there was a whole bunch of offense throughout Day one.
- I don't like how Esp just kind of shoots down mine and Scrambles arguments with "lol we shouldn't be discussing this here" at the top of page 4. But as I said earlier I don't really see that as a scum tell just kind of rude.
-Wait, wait, wait wait... Funky's only content post of day one.
funkyzafara wrote:
Mr Nobody:
He's been very defensive, doing a couple of OMGUS votes, but I am not sure if that is actually a suspicious thing, as everyone is defensive for themselves if voted against. Still doesn't stop me from seeing scummy behavior here though.
Scrambles:
I cannot justify why, but I just have a bad feeling about you, sorry. It may be your avatar, or maybe I'm just reading your posts wrong, but you definitely seem scummy to me xD.
Esp:
The whole "teaming up" with Nobody in the early start of the topic, on top of the now, seemingly know-it-all IC, makes me suspicious against you.
Anyone else:
There's not anyone else I've really "noticed" being scummy yet, but I am still suspicious of everyone.
All-in-all I really don't see anyone I can fully vote on, as I am still very torn.
Suspicious of 3 people. One of them being the top suspect of Day 1. But no vote. You say you're very torn but that's fence sitting. And why is noticed in quotation marks? I find that strange. I wish I would have noticed this earlier.
Day 2-
-Esp vanishes. while supposedly doing a reread. Which I don't think we ever got the analysis of.
-Funky appears to defend himself and vote mallow with the reason
funkyzafara wrote: mallow, you have some good points in your post, and I agree, Bob does need to make an impression fast, and he did that by voting for you. However, it seems as if you would've actually wanted to vote for him, but decided to vote for Espeonage instead, so it wouldn't seem like an OMGUS vote. However you did this, without putting up any points as to what Espeonage did that was scummy.
VOTE: mallowgeno
Which to me reads, "I'll change my mind as soon as the heats off you but I need people to think I'm against you"
-Bob joins the game and quickly comes off to everyone as protown. I find the way he led the town against mallow kind of scary though. Because Mallow flipped scum it might make him seem almost confirmed town but that might be exactly what he wanted. The aggressiveness of it makes me think he is really scum hunting though.
-I don't like how funky and I were the only ones Mallow called town. It makes me slightly more suspicious of Funky but the case could also be used against myself. I know my alignment but none of you do so that point doesn't hold much weight to anyone besides me.
-I'm also not really sure how to take Bob's reaction to my hammer vote. It was a mistake but he bought it really fast, especially considering he was attacking Mallow for his quick hammer the day before. Trendall's reaction was the one I expected out of almost everyone.
Day 3-
-Hey look Esp's back! And he provides some crap logic about process of elimination to try and vote me!And he spells my name wrong...twice.
-I still don't like Bob's IC set up there... but he has explained it.
-Ok this post right here is giving me red flags.
Espeonage wrote:You are more dangerous as scum in lylo as you would have a better chance of confising the town than Funky. Consider it a compliment.
I, myself would rather not confuse the town so I don'/t know HOW that is a compliment. So I'm either seeing that as a trap to try and set me up by agreeing to it, or that's how you're trying to get the town to play. Either way is upping your scumminess to me.
-Funky extreme buddying up to Bob. Bob notices this and calls Funky out on it though which makes Bob seem more pro town and Funky seem more like scum to me. Funky continues to fence sit and follow Bob around by listing Esp as his top scum read but not voting him until he is pressured because he didn't vote.
-I also don't like Esp bringing up his meta to try and defend himself. I don't think meta is a good argument. At all. Especially if brought up by the person themselves.
People
Funky:
My top pick for scum right now. I'm thinking he's trying to active lurk too much. He's doing a lot of fence sitting, trying not to stand out until he's pressured. Then he follows Bob. I don't like it.
Esp:
He's feeling really scummy to me as well. His lack of content while still trying to look productive is starting to catch up. He was able to hide it through IC posts on day one but it's like he's not even trying anymore. Esp, we aren't mind readers. Please explain why you've determined Bob and Trendall as town and what exactly in Scrambles ISO puts me infront of Funky for your vote.
Bob:
Most likely protown. I don't know for sure though. His town leading is what's making me the most suspicious.
Trendall:
I'm most confident in my read that he's town. He seems like he's trying to think from both perspectives to find the motivations behind peoples posts instead of just jumping to conclusions.
I'll end this post with my vote.
VOTE: Funky
. Very different meanings. 
. Mallow being an SE means he should've had enough experience not to hammer that quickly but he's only played 2 games. It's still not a lot and he might still be easily influenced. Not saying it's truly justified but putting pressure on people just for having experience isn't really fair.